Knives - what should I look for?

shortbun

<font color=green>Peacenik<br><font color=purple><
Joined
Aug 21, 1999
Messages
18,346
It's been a long time since I bought knives, like 30 years. I need to replace everything. Alas-expensive! I saw a set at Costco for $170: 8 knives and a sharpener. I almost bought them thinking that for that price they'd hold up and make me happy but then I thought- 'ask the DIS before you make ANY major purchase!" lol! Seriously, you guys know everything!!! I'm willing to pay more but as we're NOT professional chefs, the $1000 sets are out. :)

Thanks in advance!

mimi
 
I would make sure they feel good in my hand, comfortable. Does the blade go all the way through the handle? What is the blade made of? Forged knives are the best and more expensive than High carbon stainless but last longer.
 
I would make sure they feel good in my hand, comfortable. Does the blade go all the way through the handle? What is the blade made of? Forged knives are the best and more expensive than High carbon stainless but last longer.

Ok, forged and blade going through the handle. Wonder what causes some to be $1000 and some to be $500 that are seemingly the same?
 
For knives that will be passed down to your kids kids, go to a restaurant supply store.

We have Victorinox. DH went to Culinary Institute of America and his set of Victorinox are still as good as his first day of school. We keep them sharp and dont put the wood handled knives in the dishwasher.
 

I saw a set at Costco for $170: 8 knives and a sharpener.
This is a clear sign of crappy knives. Good knives would never be packaged with a sharpener because they should only be sharpened professionally. By comparison, good knives are often packaged with a honing steel. Generally, they wouldn't bother packaging crappy knives with a honing steel. (However, the lack of packaging with a honing steel shouldn't be interpreted negatively: The very best knives are always sold individually, without any other knives or a honing steel.)

This really points out, though, the main issue with knives: Beyond the obvious (poorly made, so that the handles are, or overall balance is, such that the knives are either uncomfortable to work with or degrade too quickly over time and eventually fail), what really makes knives bad is poor (typically unprofessional) sharpening, and inattention to honing. A commercial sharpener could so badly wreck a blade that it is more difficult (and perhaps less safe) to use. They can even cause such damage that professional sharpening may be unable to effect recovery, without taking off a substantial amount of material (and therefore severely undercutting the life of the blade).

Most of us would be better off buying even marginally crappy blades, but using a honing steel before every use, and having them professionally sharpened regularly.

(While I'm pretty consistent with regard to honing, I'm pretty irresponsible with regard to sharpening.)
 
I bought Cutco knives over 20 years ago and they are still woderful..
 
Cutco is good. DH has Henckels. Good knives that are goign to last you a long time won't be cheap. By the same token, there's nothing that says that you can't buy a cheap set of knives and replace them every few years.

For DH, who is a chef (not professionally, but he could be...does all the cooking and is reknowned among our friends for being a chef!) cheap knives were not an option, hence the Henckels. One of the things is that the blade goes all the way through the handle. Another good brand is Wusthoph (?spelling).
 
This is a clear sign of crappy knives. Good knives would never be packaged with a sharpener because they should only be sharpened professionally. By comparison, good knives are often packaged with a honing steel. Generally, they wouldn't bother packaging crappy knives with a honing steel. (However, the lack of packaging with a honing steel shouldn't be interpreted negatively: The very best knives are always sold individually, without any other knives or a honing steel.)

This really points out, though, the main issue with knives: Beyond the obvious (poorly made, so that the handles are, or overall balance is, such that the knives are either uncomfortable to work with or degrade too quickly over time and eventually fail), what really makes knives bad is poor (typically unprofessional) sharpening, and inattention to honing. A commercial sharpener could so badly wreck a blade that it is more difficult (and perhaps less safe) to use. They can even cause such damage that professional sharpening may be unable to effect recovery, without taking off a substantial amount of material (and therefore severely undercutting the life of the blade).

Most of us would be better off buying even marginally crappy blades, but using a honing steel before every use, and having them professionally sharpened regularly.

(While I'm pretty consistent with regard to honing, I'm pretty irresponsible with regard to sharpening.)

Well, this is lots of good information. The 'sharpener' that I mentioned was actually a honing steel. I'm just a bumpkin when it comes to knives and terminology. I might go back and look at those knives in Costco. I'm pretty sure they were Henkels.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom