Kids and R rated Movies

sharbear

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 28, 2001
Messages
1,789
I have a 14 year old DS who is a freshman in HS. Last week they had a week in school where they had a variety of activities. Friday was supposed to be a team building exercise that was to be held outside but was canceled due to bad weather. Instead they went to bowling and a movie. I had no idea that they were doing this and found out after it was over that they had seen 8 mile, a R-rated movie.

What do you think of this, should the school let kids in a school sponsered activity see a R-rated movie? The chaperon was the head football and baseball coach. I think that this showed very poor judgement and we don't allow our 14 yo to see R movies. My DH says that I am in the minority and that most parents of 14yo let their kids go to R movies.
 
no Im with you! I would NOT be a happy camper at all!!!

especially with that movie!
 
No way!! I would notify the schoolboard!!!!!!!!
 
Words fail me!!! I can't even describe how furious I'd be. What happened to this teacher's basic common sense? I'd be on the phone to other parents this morning .... I'm quite sure you're not the only one and that "all the other parents" do not agree with this. Then, I'd be on the phone to the principal and encouraging other like-minded parents to do the same. I'm not making a judgement on parents who choose to allow their kids to see this.
What 'burns my britches' is that the school made this choice for all parents! It's not like the parents who don't approve of this can have their kids 'un-see' it.
 

I was allowed to see R Rated Movies in High School. What makes 8 Mile R Rated? Does anyone know? Too many cuss words? Worse is said in boys locker rooms also girls locker rooms for that matter.

I do agree that schools should not take students under 17yrs old to see R rated movies. It should be up to the parents whether or not they allow their childern to see R rated movies before the age of 17 or not. Not for nothing how did they do this without getting permission silps signed? I would contact your local school committee people and express concern and ask them to look into what happened.
 
I think it depends on what it is the R rated movie. Some cussing doesnt bother me but I wouldnt want my ds 15 be watching a movie with nudity and sex. Both he and my 12 yr old are allowed to see R rated movies depending on why the R rating.
If my ds football coach took him to see a movie I would have let him see anyway it wouldnt bother me.
 
Not just that it was an R-rated movie (our school district would NEVER allow that), but you didn't know.
Here they can not go on any field trip without a specific permisision slip signed by a parent.

I would hope that teacher(s) would be in a lot of trouble!
 
I have to say that I'm appalled, but not necessarily surprised about this. The schools around here often act as though our children belong to them first & us second - making decisions about what is okay for them to do or see.

IMO no school or school representative should make the blanket decision that viewing an R-rated film is okay for students under age. Frankly, I question whether a school should take students of ANY age to see R-rated films without first contacting the parents - regardless of the reason for the rating.

My first response, though, when reading this was that they took the students away from the building without first notifying the parents & obtaining their permission! I can't believe they did that! Totally unacceptable! :mad:

Deb
 
I've let my son (15 and in 9th grade) watch a couple of R-rated movies, but only after I judged why they got that rating. I think that is up to the parents and not anyone at the school. Bad judgement on somebody's part.
 
I think it showed very poor judgement. I don't understand why there is no "permission slip" policy in place.
If something were to happen the school/coach could be sued.
 
I want to say that I did sign a permission slip for him to leave the building. We sign a blanket permission slip at the beginning of the year. This is an activity that lasts a week and there are all kinds of "opportunities" for the week. On Monday they did a service project, Tuesday he went golfing with the principal, Wed. was a cultural awareness day and Thursday he went on a 18 mile bike ride. Friday was supposed to be a rope climbing exercise in team building at the Boy Scout Camp but it was canceled. So you could either stay at school and watch movies and play ping-pong or go bowling and the movies. I thought that he was going to the Boy Scout Camp but things got changed. I don't have a problem with him going to the movies but I am suprised that they saw a r-rated movie without me knowing. I hear that 8 Mile is R-rated because of profanity and if he wanted to see it I would think about letting him.

I have a really good friend whose husband is on the school board. I'm going to call her and find out what the fallout was, I'm sure that somebody has complained. I talked to a friend on Friday night and she felt kind of like I did. Not sure what to think but convinced that someone made a poor judgement.
 
Yes, that coach should be reprimanded for 1) not obtaining permission slip 2) how did the kids get there, in a personal car?

3) R rated is R rated for a reason 17 and over. I would never in a million years let a child who could barely watch PG 13 even think about a R rated movie.

I was never allowed to watch them either. In fact, I remember in sophmore english class we had to write a paper on the Breakfast Club--a current popular movie at the time. I couldn't watch the movie, it was rated R. I got my friend to watch the movie, and then I called her so I could do the report.
 
Wow, that really surprises me that the theater even allowed them to see the movie.

My DS was at a soccer tournament in North Carolina this weekend. The games were cancelled so they went to the movies. The boys are all 17 or will be 17 in a few months. They wanted to see 8 Mile but in NC you have to be 18 to see R-rated movies. The theater would not allow them to buy tickets.

I think it is totally inapproprate for a school sponsored function to take them to an R-rated movie without express permission from the parents.
 
While its always a personal decision, and even if a lot of parents do let their kids see R rated movies, there is no way a coach should have taken underage kids there. That is for the parents to decide.
Even if I were one of the parents who would let my kids see an R rated movie, I would still feel that was out of line for him to take the kids. Defintiely not right!
 
In my opinion it doesn't matter what the movie was rated R for, I think it is wrong to take a bunch of 14 & 15 year olds to see a rated R movie w/o getting permission from the parents before hand. I think the coach showed very poor judgement in my opinion.
 
I'd be ticked off and definitely say something. I have a 9 year old DS who just this weekend mentioned something about something being "whacked."
complain.gif
Since we don't watch the Soprano's I'm guessing someone at school has seen it or heard something from it! Nine year olds have NO business watching a show like that. You wonder if some parents have common sense. :mad:
 
I just don't get it.... In another post, a student had his Binaca spray confiscated because it "contains" alcohol. :confused: I guess that's zero tolerance.....

In your DS's case, the coach determined it was acceptable for him to take the kids without the parents' consent. :mad: We know that the kids are being "watched", but who is watching the teachers? What if something had happened to the kids?

While there may be parents that would give consent to their kids to see an R rated movie, the parents must be notified beforehand. You definitely need to say something.:mad:
 
Originally posted by Pin Wizard
I'd be ticked off and definitely say something. I have a 9 year old DS who just this weekend mentioned something about something being "whacked."
complain.gif
Since we don't watch the Soprano's I'm guessing someone at school has seen it or heard something from it! Nine year olds have NO business watching a show like that. You wonder if some parents have common sense. :mad:

Just as an FYI the word "whacked" can have two different meanings.

If "something" as you noted above is "whacked" that means it is crazy, out the ordinary. Example, "Did you see the shirt Johnny has on today? Is it "whacked".

The second meaning is if "someone" got "whacked". The Soprano version. Example "Raplhie was "whacked" two weeks ago." In this case whacked does mean to kill someone.


I am sure you know how your son used the word just an FYI that the word can mean a couple of different things.
 
I agree with the above posters' thoughts and comments. Totally unacceptable behavior and the school should be questioned at to, why.
 
I just ran across this, seems fitting to post it here........


Something for parents to think about

A father of some teenage children had the family rule that they could not attend PG-13 or R rated movies. His three teens wanted to see the particular popular movie that was playing at local theaters. It was rated PG-13.

The teens interviewed friends and even some members of their family's church to find out what was offensive in the movie. The teens made a list of pros and cons about the movie to use to convince their dad that they should be allowed to see it.

The cons that it contained ONLY 3 swear words, the ONLY violence was a building exploding (and you see that on the TV all the time they said), and you actually did not "see" the couple in the movie having sex-it was just implied sex, off camera.

The pros were that it was a popular move-a blockbuster. Everyone was seeing it. If the teens saw the movie then they would not feel left out when their friends discussed it. The movie contained a good story and plot. It had some great adventure and suspense in it. There were some fantastic special effects in this movie. The movie's stars were some of the most talented actors in Hollywood. It probably would be nominated for several awards.
Many of the members of their Christian church had even seen the movie and said it wasn't "very bad." Therefore, since there more pros than con the teens said they were asking their father to reconsider his position on this ONE movie and let them have permission to go see it.

The father looked at the list and thought for a few minutes. He said he could tell his children had spent some time and though on this request. He asked if he could have a day to think about it before making his decision. The teens were thrilled thinking: "Now we've got him! Our argument is too goo! Dad can't turn us down!" So they happily agreed to let him have a day to think about their request.

The next evening the father called in his three teenagers, who were smiling smugly, into the living room. There on the coffee table he had a plate of brownies. The teens were puzzled. The father told his children he had thought about their request and had decided that if they would eat a brownie then he would let them go to the movie. But just like the movie, the brownies have pros and cons.

The pros were that they were made the finest chocolate and other good ingredients. They had the added special effect of yummy walnuts in them. The brownies were moist and fresh with wonderful chocolate frosting on top. He had made these fantastic brownies using an award-winning recipe. And best of all, the brownies had been made lovingly by the hand of their own father.

The brownies only had one con. He had included a bit of a special ingredient. The brownies also contained just a little bit of dog poop. But he had mixed the dough well-they probably would not even be able to taste the dog poop and he had baked it at 350 degrees so any bacteria or germs from the dog poop had probably been destroyed.

Therefore, if any of his children could stand to eat brownies which included just a "a little bit of crap" and not be affected by it, then he knew they would also be able to see the movie with "just a little bit of smut" and not be affected.

Of course, none of the teens would eat the brownies and the smug smiles had left their faces. Only Dad was smiling smugly as they left the room. Now when the teenagers ask permission to do something he is apposed to the father just asks, " Would you like me to whip up a batch of my special brownies?"
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter
Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom