Kids and E Books

DVCLiz

<font color=00cc00>That's me - proud defender of t
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
10,699
I just saw this article and found it interesting. In light of the fact that so many DISers are interested in ereaders, I was curious what people thought about kids and reading ebooks.

If you use an ereader, how do you feel about your kids using them? At what age, if ever? Do you think it is more about the experience of reading a paper book at that age, or about developing a lifelong habit of reading no matter what the medium?

Personally, I think paper picture books for kids up to preschool age should always be a part of a child's experience, for the tactile experience if nothing else, but also for the original artwork in the original size. Otherwise, though, "curling up with a good book" is about the story and spending time with a reading parent, so I would be fine with an ereader like an iPad that showed color illustrations.

And I would be totally in favor of kids having ereaders for pleasure reading of novels. It's been such a great new tool for my reading, and for those of my daughters (who were 14 and 19 when they first got my hand-me-down Kindles), that I'd like to see a kid-friendly ereader on the market.

Survey: Children like e-books, parents not so much
HILLEL ITALIE
From Associated Press
September 29, 2010 8:40 AM EDT
NEW YORK (AP) — Children are ready to try e-books, with some thinking that a bigger selection of electronic texts would make reading for fun even more fun, according to a new study. But a solid majority of parents aren't planning to join the digital revolution.

The 2010 Kids and Family Reading Report, released Wednesday and commissioned by Scholastic Inc., offers a mixed portrait of e-books and families. Around six out of 10 of those between ages 9 and 17 say they're interested in reading on an electronic device such as the Kindle or the iPad. Around one out of three from the same age group say they'd read more "for fun" if more books were available on a digital reader.

Among the books that can't be downloaded: the "Harry Potter" series, published in the U.S. by Scholastic. J.K. Rowling has said she prefers her work to be read on paper.

The e-market has grown rapidly since 2007 and the launch of Amazon.com's Kindle device, from less than 1 percent of overall sales to between 5 to 10 percent, publishers say. But the new report is also the latest to show substantial resistance. Just 6 percent of parents surveyed have an electronic reading device, while 76 percent say they have no plans to buy one. Sixteen percent plan to have one within the following year.

In a recent Harris Poll of adults, 80 percent said they were not likely to get an e-reader.

"I'm not surprised to know that. I think we're still at the beginning of e-books," said Scholastic Book Club president Judy Newman, adding that the expense of digital devices was a likely problem for potential e-book fans.

The 2010 report shows, as other studies have, a decline in reading for fun as children grow older. More than half read for fun between ages 6 and 8, but the percentage drops to around 25 percent by ages 15 through 17 and just 20 percent for boys in that age group. Newman sees technology as both a problem and possible solution.

"We know that around age 8 they (children) start to lose interest in reading," Newman says. "Obviously, digital media is competing for kids' attention. It's very important that we as publishers make sure we're engaging kids in reading for fun. There's an opportunity to use technology to engage kids. ... We can have great content presented in a digital way."

The Kids and Family report was compiled by the Harrison Group, a marketing and research consulting firm. The survey was conducted in the spring of 2010, with 1,045 children and 1,045 parents interviewed. The margin of error is plus or minus 3.2 percentage points.
 
My 8 year always wants to read on my Nook. She has read chapters of books that she would never have attempted to read because the cover or the thickness of the book was not to her liking.

For example we own Alice In Wonderland and The Secret Garden both as an Ebook and as a bound book. She has read chapters of both of these books while bored at doctors office but would never read the bound book.

The novelty of the ebook is huge for kids and if it gets them reading, I'm all for it.

I do love good illustrated books and would hate those to ever go away. A book like Mercy Watson should never be read as an Ebook.
 
My 8 year always wants to read on my Nook. She has read chapters of books that she would never have attempted to read because the cover or the thickness of the book was not to her liking.

For example we own Alice In Wonderland and The Secret Garden both as an Ebook and as a bound book. She has read chapters of both of these books while bored at doctors office but would never read the bound book.

The novelty of the ebook is huge for kids and if it gets them reading, I'm all for it.

I do love good illustrated books and would hate those to ever go away. A book like Mercy Watson should never be read as an Ebook.

Good point-a lot of kids look a the size of a book and are turned off-heck, a lot of ADULTS won't read "big" books :lmao:.

My kids haven't asked for one but if they did I would probably get them one. DS18 is using some e-textbooks, which are GREAT. Our twins don't like to read books online on the computer but an e-reader is much more like a book.

I keep going back and forth about getting one for myself. I think it will be on my Christmas list this year mainly because it is either that or buy some new bookshelves because I am out of room on the ones I have. I like to re-read books so I keep them. This will be a much more organized way to do that.
 
I don't think it's important "how" they read, it's just important that they read!
 

Once DS is reading, I'll happily let him read from a Kindle.

DH told me that an elementary school bought a bunch of Kindles and let the kids bring them home for the summer. When school started, they found that a significant number of the kids had read 80-90% of the summer reading list, when normally the majority read NOTHING from the reading list, and a minority would read 10% or so. It really made a difference in how much was read!

And I think JKR is off her rocker...there is NOTHING more magical looking, at least book-related, than how the Kindle changes pages. Her books would be beyond perfect on a Kindle. She thought of moving portraits, but wants us to still read on paper??? Whatever, JK...I love her books and admire what she's done, but I don't think she's thought through some of the other stuff....
 
I have no problem with it and have downloaded a couple books for DD13. We use the Barnes and Noble that allows you to read eBooks on the computer without an eReader.

As someone already said: as long as they are reading - and the eBooks are often cheaper, so they can get that many more books!!!!

I use it for books I want to save money on and am pretty sure I won't like it enough to keep on the shelf.....still old school that way.:)
 
I am buying one for my DD for her 14th birthday in a couple of weeks.

I am not worried about her losing 'the experience' of reading paper books. They still exist, and she's not going to be reading on the Nook exclusively to the detriment of all other books.

When my 7 year old gets a bit bigger and becomes a better reader, he'll likely end up with one, too...perhaps around 10/11/12 because I'm sure they will be more common by then. But again, he'll still have the 'experience' of paper books.

More important that they have a love of reading, no matter what the source (even reading online is reading!).
 
I always keep a book DD(7) enjoys on my Nook. She doesn't read that way all the time - far from it - but it is handy when we are waiting for a seat in a restaurant or for an appointment.
 
DH and I are debating about this right now. He wants to get DD12 a Kindle for Christmas since she is an avid bookworm. But I want to first check with her school to see if it would be allowed. They have silent reading for an hour every day and I want to be sure she would be able to use it. Then I'd also worry about it getting stolen. Just not sure what to do yet.
 
DD12 has downloaded a bunch of classics to the kindle app on her itouch. They are free on the kindle store and she liked being able to "book shop" for free! Several she has started reading on the app and gotten into enough to get the "real" book from the libarary. If she had a larger actual ereader, I'm sure she would have read the whole thing on there. But, as Aneille points out, many of these books I'd never have been able to get her to pick up otherwise. Kids do judge books by their covers often.
 
DH and I are debating about this right now. He wants to get DD12 a Kindle for Christmas since she is an avid bookworm. But I want to first check with her school to see if it would be allowed. They have silent reading for an hour every day and I want to be sure she would be able to use it. Then I'd also worry about it getting stolen. Just not sure what to do yet.

Just like an IPod, I would never send something like this to school. I would have her take out a library book from the school library for her in school reading. They really have an HOUR of silent reading each day??? That is a LOT of class time.
 
We are getting our 9 year old daughter one for Christmas. It's all she really wants. She borrows mine and my husband now and loves to use it.

I do think ereaders will be "the way of the future" and if it gets them to read more, I think it is great.

edited to add:

I won't let her take her Kindle to school though.
 
Just like an IPod, I would never send something like this to school. I would have her take out a library book from the school library for her in school reading. They really have an HOUR of silent reading each day??? That is a LOT of class time.

She doesn't use the school library because they don't have enough books in her level. We use the public library and we buy books a lot. I don't want to get an ebook if I'm still going to have to be buying bound books. Yes, reading is an hour. During that time the teacher works one on one with a student doing literacy testing. This is required in grades 2-6. (I'm a special ed para at the same school) The students are also required to write a letter to the teacher when they've finished a book. Ten books per trimester. DD met that requirement two weeks ago and the tri is over mid-Nov!:) I really have no problem with ereaders. I deal with kids every day that need to be reading something!
 
She doesn't use the school library because they don't have enough books in her level. We use the public library and we buy books a lot. I don't want to get an ebook if I'm still going to have to be buying bound books. Yes, reading is an hour. During that time the teacher works one on one with a student doing literacy testing. This is required in grades 2-6. (I'm a special ed para at the same school) The students are also required to write a letter to the teacher when they've finished a book. Ten books per trimester. DD met that requirement two weeks ago and the tri is over mid-Nov!:) I really have no problem with ereaders. I deal with kids every day that need to be reading something!

I don't have a problem with the e-readers, I have a problem with a $150 item gone "missing" at school :lmao:.
 
I don't have a problem with the e-readers, I have a problem with a $150 item gone "missing" at school :lmao:.

True. But then my kids take their iPods to school with the understanding if they come up missing, I'm not replacing them.
 
...
And I think JKR is off her rocker...there is NOTHING more magical looking, at least book-related, than how the Kindle changes pages. Her books would be beyond perfect on a Kindle. She thought of moving portraits, but wants us to still read on paper??? Whatever, JK...I love her books and admire what she's done, but I don't think she's thought through some of the other stuff....

Oh, I think that she has thought it through VERY thoroughly. Didn't you ever notice that JKR's magical world has no "screen entertainment" analogies of any kind? There is wizarding Wireless (radio), but nothing that is analogous to television or motion pictures, unless you count the Pensieve. The moving portraits don't let you play games or watch stories, they just let you talk to people in a limited way; they are not passive entertainment. Books in that world are still books, even if they can bite: they don't read themselves out loud. She could easily have had them do that, but chose not to.

My own opinion on the original question is that right now it's a moot point because modern books for young children depend on color illustrations, which lets out all e-readers other than the iPad. Beyond that I'd say that they will have to get a lot more sturdy and a lot less expensive before they will become practical for use by the preschool and primary school set. Trust me; the littles are rough on books.
 
Oh, I think that she has thought it through VERY thoroughly. Didn't you ever notice that JKR's magical world has no "screen entertainment" analogies of any kind? There is wizarding Wireless (radio), but nothing that is analogous to television or motion pictures, unless you count the Pensieve. The moving portraits don't let you play games or watch stories, they just let you talk to people in a limited way; they are not passive entertainment. Books in that world are still books, even if they can bite: they don't read themselves out loud. She could easily have had them do that, but chose not to.

My own opinion on the original question is that right now it's a moot point because modern books for young children depend on color illustrations, which lets out all e-readers other than the iPad. Beyond that I'd say that they will have to get a lot more sturdy and a lot less expensive before they will become practical for use by the preschool and primary school set. Trust me; the littles are rough on books.

I asked this question because picture books are very important for pre reading and having pictures in early reading books help kids learn how to read. They also teach kids how to make inferences from the pictures to what will happen next in the book. Both are VERY important cognitive development stages for kids.
 
I asked this question because picture books are very important for pre reading and having pictures in early reading books help kids learn how to read. They also teach kids how to make inferences from the pictures to what will happen next in the book. Both are VERY important cognitive development stages for kids.

E-readers can handle B/W illustrations, but it is the color that is the imperative from a marketing standpoint. Publishers just don't DO kid's picture books in black and white anymore, except as rare novelties.
 
I'm getting my dd12 the nook for Christmas, but she won't be able to use it in school. My dd loves to read so thats not an issue for us but if it makes kids in general more interested in reading, I'm all for it at any age.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom