As you might expect, some things were much better than hoped for, other items not so much. For what it's worth, here are the things that get my thumbs up/down awards.

Keep venues open later. It was such a drag watching the ship fold up and close down at midnight. Granted, staying up till 4am drinking, or being in the hot tub till dawn has it's consequences, but I should be able to make that choice.

Kids Clubs were fantastic! With so many age groupings, age related activities are easily coordinated. I have yet to hear about folks who's kids didn't WANT to go there.(Fussy, clingy kids excepted). My two boys loved it. DS14 spent just about every ship-board minute either sleeping, eating, playing in the arcade, hanging out at The Stack, or doing Stack related activities (no particular order). OB was similar in his quest for independence and also was engrossed in Ocean Club stuff and never had us paged.

Bring out Mickey for photo ops more often! This is a
DISNEY cruise, so please bring out our beloved icon and show him off. Also, if I get in line for a pic w/ mic, please don't swap him out for another character when his time is up and I'm nearing the head of the line. Bringing out Mickey2 as soon as Mickey1 is out of sight should solve any illusion problems. Or how about a Mickey room for stop by anytime afternoon pictures like in the parks?

Giveaways.
DCL gives away all kinds of stuff. Hats, keychains, laynards, flashlight, etc. for attending stuff from Bingo to trivia. A limited number of people get goodies for participating, or just luck of the draw. DCL and
Castaway Club members also get bonus stuff for attending the sales meetings.

Fix the character breakfast to make it like the in park character breakfasts. Partitioning off the room and bring out two sets of characters might help. This goes hand in hand with getting more Mickey interaction.

Extra CM's were a great help. I didn't notice this until later in the week, but they were very good at giving you as short a wait as possible. Friday night at Shutters, Sat am at Customer Service, or even at the Cay where there were extra CM's on hand just in case, most lines were 10 mins or less.

Either enlarge the smoking area, or have alcohol free zones. Discrimination against smokers has gotten out of hand, no matter how misguided. Anybody who complains about second hand cigarette smoke outside, on a windy deck, just doesn't have enough to complain about. (The full-time smokers made me write this, right John?)

Shutters. For a place I initially thought would be a huge rip-off, I am now singing their praises. With knowledgeable photographers who take multiple shots, great backgrounds, cool dated borders, and most importantly, you are able to pick which ones you want, you WILL take home THE most personalized mementos. I had a real hard time justifing the cost of them until I put it in perspective. Considering the total cost of the entire vacation, it's only another 1-3%

High gift shop prices of forgotten items. The shops must be embarrassed at the price they charge for items like batteries and sunscreen because finding prices is a challenge. Being beaten up to the tune of 10 dollars for something that should cost 2 or 3 bucks shouldn't happen if the get on the boat cost is the highest in the industry. Just like the old saying, if you have to ask, you probably can't afford it.

The entire experience! Although a bit of advice to all financiers. Begin to complain around Thursday, find something (anything) to moan about on Friday, and be sure to grumble on the way home. Now when the subject of another cruise comes up, you have laid the groundwork for nixing the idea before it gains momentum, thereby saving you literally thousands of dollars. (maybe you'll have better luck with this strategy than I did). Yes I did have a blast. It was far more fun than I dreamed it would be. But until I can find a better way to do it again, it might be a while before we see deck 9 again.