Just Back! Reviews of Wishes and Illuminations: ROE

time101

Mouseketeer
Joined
Nov 23, 2000
Messages
193
Well, I never thought I'd say this. I'm bracing myself right now. Here goes:

The MK fireworks show has now passed up Illuminations as being the best in the world (or at least on Disney property).

I have always been a lifelong Illuminations fan ever since its first incarnation in the early '80s. But Wishes is something special. It is unforgettable. It even beats out Disneyland's Believe!

Perhaps it helped that we wound up with a "perfect view". Although, from what I've been reading on other threads, for this show there seems to be no shortage of perfect views. We stood on the west (left facing the castle) side of the hub. So we had a perfect view of the castle with the fireworks behind it. To get the full effect, it helps to see the castle since various shapes and colors are projected on it during the show to synchronize with the fireworks.

As for the fireworks themselves, I had no idea that such shapes were even possible. Stars, hearts, waterfalls, multi-colored flowers. Incredible. And as usual, everything is in perfect synch to the soundtrack.

As for Illuminations: ROE, I may be in the minority, but I really think this version pales not only in comparison to Wishes, but even to earlier versions of Illuminations.

We visited WDW last in 2000 when ROE premiered. We had the same reaction then as we have now. Here's what we like about ROE: The flames are cool, both around lagoon and in the middle of the lagoon. The initial "comet" effect with the sound is cool. The "breath" blowing out the flames is a nice effect. The finale of white fireworks making it seem like daytime is great. That's about it.

What we don't like: As technologically advanced as the spinning globe is, I don't care for it. From most positions around the lagoon, you can't even make out what half of the images are. I know because one night, we literally walked around the lagoon during the show. And those portions of the show drag on soooo long. We wanna see lasers and fireworks!

My emotional attachment to Illuminations did not start with ROE. It started with the first version, which I consider superior. I would much rather have Illuminations feature each individual country around the lagoon, with lights, lasers and songs. I still remember seeing France light up with the "Moulin Rouge" sign on top, lasers pointing to the country, and hearing the sound of French music. I remember the strains of "Rhapsody in Blue" as the lasers finally pointed to the American Adventure. It was incredible. And of course, I always liked the spinning globe effect projected onto Spaceship Earth after the show from the American Adventure.

Oh well. Maybe I'll get my way in the future and Disney will go back to an individual nation salute show. But if they do, I certainly hope they will finally Illuminate Norway and Morocco. I always feel sorry for those countries during Illuminations.

Anyway, those are just my opinions! :p
 
Great review, glad you liked Wishes. I was never much of a fireworks fan, and have only seen the ones during MVMCP. However with all the glowing reviews that I have read here about how great Wishes really is, I will make it a point to see these fireworks.

:Pinkbounc :bounce: :Pinkbounc :bounce:
 
Your review of Illuminations is exactly how I felt about it the last time I watched it. My friend and I had a really good view of the globe and I was like, wow, I never realized just what was on there! It's very cool if you are close enough to see it but stinks and drags on if you are too far away or have poor eyesight. Then I also got to thinking, they don't do this anymore, they don't do that anymore and the globe effect on Spaceship Earth was the main thing I commented on. I really miss that! It's still a good show but you are right, Wishes is better and Illuminations is just a shadow of it's former self. :)
 
Thanks so much for your post. My mom and I are going in less than 3 weeks (yippee!) and are looking forward to seeing Wishes. Illuminations was always a don't miss for me, but I agree with you that this newest incarnation is a let down after the earlier one. I don't enjoy the looooong movie on the globe, I too want to see the pyrotechnics and lasers! I am not a huge Fantasmic fan either. I think the movie scenes on the water sprays are too long.

Thanks again and I am glad you enjoyed your trip!
 

Thanks for the awesome review! :D I was already so excited about seeing the new show...now I can't hardly stand it :faint: Move timer...MOVE! :hyper:

I love Illuminations (always my favorite...and we usually see it as many times as we can), but my first time was in 2000...so I've only seen ROE. You make me wish I had seen the previous one!

So...viewing Wishes on the hub is not 'too close' to see everything? By 'hub'...you all are talking about right on that circle in front of the castle...right? Excuse my lack of Disney Knowledge :blush: That's why I need you guys sooooo much :crazy:
 
We just got back too (11/15 - 23) and we saw the MK fireworks the four nights we were at the Polynesian (when we moved over to the YC we saw ROE every night). Wishes is incredible!!!!!! As much as we love ROE, these fireworks are now our favorite! We saw them twice from our room and twice from the park. My favorite was the night we had the kids in the neverland club and DH & I saw them just outside of Mickey's Philharmagic so it was like we were under them - wonderful!!

For all of you going soon - DON'T MISS THIS SHOW!!!!!!

Jill
 
Originally posted by pewing
Thanks for the awesome review! :D I was already so excited about seeing the new show...now I can't hardly stand it :faint: Move timer...MOVE! :hyper:

I love Illuminations (always my favorite...and we usually see it as many times as we can), but my first time was in 2000...so I've only seen ROE. You make me wish I had seen the previous one!

So...viewing Wishes on the hub is not 'too close' to see everything? By 'hub'...you all are talking about right on that circle in front of the castle...right? Excuse my lack of Disney Knowledge :blush: That's why I need you guys sooooo much :crazy:

Yup...that's the hub!:teeth:
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE




DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top Bottom