We just got back as well- 9/11-9/17. We were unable to get a preferred room, and we got a room on the back of the last Broadway building, so quite a bit from Melody Hall. We saw all the cool towel animals in all the windows, and despite leaving tips, and my 8 y.o. DS writing a cute note/drawing the last day, we never saw one. And most of all, the bus situation is HORRENDOUS! I can not believe how many hours we wasted because we relied on Disney transportation. The room was fine, nothing spectacular, but overall clean. I was surprised to hear that they were all rehabbed, because there was a lot of rust in the bathroom- the door hinges, the sprinkler covers. We still had a great time, and face it, $82 a night including all your meals can't be beat, but I doubt we will ever stay at an All-Stars again, and if for some reason we did, I would NEVER consider doing it without renting a car.