I've stayed at AKL three times within the past year and a half, and we are returning for our fourth visit in February. The first trip wasn't that great. I got very sick our second day there, spent a couple of days in the room, and then we ended up cutting our trip short by a few days to come home. This is where we experienced the "magic" of WDW. Our mousekeeper, Jill, couldn't have been warmer and more attentive if we were her own family. She respected our privacy and understood that we didn't want the normal level of mousekeeping due to my illness. Nevertheless, she checked in on us each and every day to make sure I was all right, and to see if there was anything I needed to help make my stay more comfortable.
When we decided to leave a few days early, my friend went downstairs to notify the front desk. They, too, were just wonderful. We told them at 6 p.m. that we were leaving the next morning by 9 a.m., and we were not charged for any of the remaining days of our reservation, even though we didn't give much notice at all. Due to some bad memories because I was sick, we hesitated returning to AKL, but decided to try again, and am so glad we did. It's my favorite Disney resort now.
I understand some of the views expressed here that some CMs don't have quite the Disney spirit you may find at some other resorts, but many of them do. We may have been lucky by running into the ones who really cared. I'm not sure what "Disney" feel you're not getting at AKL, but I've always felt that I was surrounded by the magic every time I've stayed there, and can't wait to get back to my home away from home.