You are going to LOVE the Fantasy. It is an awesome ship! DH and I sailed out of NYC on the Magic, too. The Magic is a great ship, too, but after sailing the Fantasy, I'm going to have trouble sailing any of the other ships. We are anxious to stay at the Poly again, too. We actually stayed there last August and I honestly didn't think it was that bad, but I am looking forward to our return trip with most of the construction done.