Jaleo or Boathouse?

Ellie Webbs

DIS Veteran
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Messages
600
So DH and I are planning on a date night during our upcoming trip and we (I) had settled on Boathouse because we (I) love seafood. On seeing some reviews of Jaleo since though we (DH) have taken an extreme liking to the Jaleo menu.
Any outstanding experiences either way? I'm happy to swap but would rather have some real life experiences, not just YouTube reviews!
 
We love both but they are very different experiences. The Boathouse is a steak and seafood house run by the Gibson's group from Chicago - gets its name from the classic boats on display outside the restaurant. It has a comfortable steakhouse vibe. Jaleo features small, shared plates and has a more adult atmosphere - at least when we went. It's far more adventurous - if you go there, trust your server to make recommendations. You can't go wrong with either of these places - both have excellent seafood.
 
So DH and I are planning on a date night during our upcoming trip and we (I) had settled on Boathouse because we (I) love seafood. On seeing some reviews of Jaleo since though we (DH) have taken an extreme liking to the Jaleo menu.
Any outstanding experiences either way? I'm happy to swap but would rather have some real life experiences, not just YouTube reviews!
We've eaten at both restaurants and enjoyed them both. Boathouse, is a family favorite whether adults only or with kids, and Jaleo, twice at WDW, and several times in Washington, DC.

Some phenomenal small plates at Jaleo; our last two times we ordered the two different chef's tasting menus and in my opinion the lesser expensive of the 2 is the better value. Great drinks with the salt air foam margarita being a favorite and the red sangria nice as well. We'll be returning there for our New Year's Eve dinner since I think it's the perfect place for a celebratory meal.

Here's a well written review another poster did complete with pictures:

https://www.disboards.com/threads/m...skippers-canteen.3761287/page-3#post-60943069
Boathouse is great as well and sometimes we just drop in w/o reservations but Jaleo is more unusual.
 
Last edited:

We did the tasting menu at Jaleo. ($75 pp?) It's great. TONs of food and we get to try a lot. The food is amazing. I love Boathouse too but I found it way overpriced.
 
/
My husband and I LOVE Jaleo!! The menu is amazing, the drinks are amazing, the staff is amazing, and owner Jose Andres is a humanitarian! This is for sure a favorite of ours!
 
Thank you everyone. It's looking like Jaleo is winning atm! Anyone recommending any stand out dishes? I'm interested in the octopus 🤔🤔🤔
 
Thank you everyone. It's looking like Jaleo is winning atm! Anyone recommending any stand out dishes? I'm interested in the octopus 🤔🤔🤔

Didn't get to try the pulpo yet since it was not on either of the chef's tasting meus we tried the last 2 times we ate there but since we plan to order from the a la carte menu next time it's a definite contender. I will say that every restaurant I've eaten octopus at WDW it was always quite tender.

This was from a review I wrote in April and I list our favorite dishes at that meal:
Oh well, still in Dodo Land, so typing w/o images continues.

Recently, the restaurant began offering 2 different tasting menus after 4:00 PM so I made sure to book a 4:15 PM reservation via opentable.com and an early and satisfying meal it was. It was difficult for the waiter to explain what was the difference between the 2 menus as no written list existed at that time. He did give me a hint though which made better sense once the food was received: the least expensive of the two menus was comprised of the less costly or Basic tapas.

This is what we had upon ordering the Jaleo Experience tasting menu:

pan cristal - toasted bread spread with a tomato confit
queso manchego- wedges of Spanish goat cheese
paleta Iberica de bellota - thin slices of a ham similar to procuitto; not carved at table
endibias- endive leaves topped with a mixture of small curd soft cheese, oranges and almond slivers. Tastes much better than it sounds + none left on the plate.
gazpacho shots- salad soup is what we call it in my home:). Served cold.
ensalada manzanas- sliced apples, fennel, cheese and nut salad.
croquettas de pollo- deep fried chicken croquettes. Quite rich and creamy with boneless meat.
espinacas - sauteed spinach with garlic.
tortilla de patatas- thin sliced potato and onion omelette. Redolent with the flavors of olive oil. Creamy texture which showed off the versatility of eggs.
gambas al ajillo- shrimps (headless) on a bed of olive oil braised leeks and tons of yummy garlic
patatas bravas- divine potato chunks with garlic and - tomato sauces. Tender with a nice crust. Prolly the tomato sauce used smoked paprika as the main spice.
butifarra con mongetes- "homemade" pork sausage with Spanish (not Mexican) styled fried white beans. Head spinningly good but we were stuffed by the time it was served so it was packed to go. And and I enjoyed it one night when we were home and there was no competition awake;).

My summation is that all of the dishes listed above are considered basic for the dining plan but it's best to double check with your server.

Our favorites?
Keep in mind that in my family veggies are just as desirable as meat in the evaluation:

endibias
croquette de pollo
gazpacho
gambas al ajillo
tortilla patatas
patatas bravas
espinacas
butifarra

We also ordered the oysters gin and tonic tapa since the man and I enjoy them and plan to order the dish again. I needed some care eating one of the oysters as it had a bit of shell in the liquid. Hopefully practice will make for perfection next time around for the kitchen staff.

For drinks, the kiddos, ordered bottles of a non alcoholic wine soda called la casera tinto de verano; one drank it all and the other 1/2 a bottle. It reminded them of the Beverly Coke product at Epcot from Italy in bitterness and acidity. Should you prefer the sweetness level of most American style sodas this is not the drink for you.

The man had a salt foamed Margarita (listed on the menu as Salt Air) and ga dang it was yummilicious and certainly will be ordered again. This is a variation on a classic margarita with no overt sweetness from fruit juices or sugar syrups; be forewarned:).

I ordered the red sangria sort of under duress as I really wanted sherry but couldn't decide which one to order, LOL. Sooo glad I went with the red wine drink instead.

As for the included desserts... I admit to wishing I could make a flan that creamy in texture. Methinks it's time for me to move off the French recipe I normally use and look to that of Spain. The second dessert was called pan chocolate and the 3 chocoholics in the party scarfed it down.

HTH
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top