Buffy, I feel your pain. I am having major issues with dd's teacher this year. She, the teacher, is fresh out of school and has NO idea how to handle 21 second graders. Her discipline idea is to have each child begin the week with 5 "dollars" and if they break "rules" they have to pull one and they can't buy big treats at the end of the week (from the goodie bin). Sounds good, right? The execution however, leaves a bit to be desired.
If you pull even one dollar, you don't get to go to the treat bin AT ALL. So if you pull a dollar on Monday, you might as well live it up the rest of the week, because your punishment doesn't get any worse! AND all sins are equal. Katie had to pull a dollar Monday because she forgot her reading book. She would have received the same punishment if she had kicked a classmate.
I asked what this was teaching her, and was told it was to help them learn responsibility. No, I said, it is teaching them to leverage their misbehavior into one week.
I told Katie that I did not care that she got in trouble for forgetting things (I would if it was REAL misbehaving). I said that her teacher could do as she wished, but that I bet the teacher had never gone a week without forgetting something, that forgetting was human and she wasn't in trouble with me.
Yeesh!