We've been to italy, but did not book through
DVC. Personally, I think you can do much better by booking something through an agency in Italy.
My daughter went with 13 co-workers last summer. They rented a villa near Siena and had a wonderful time.
The II location in Gavorrano is probably very nice, but it's not near any major cities or sites you might want to visit.
We booked a cottage in Castellina in Chianti for two weeks in October through the same agency my daughter used. So far they have been very helpful and easy to work with. I'll let you know more when we return.
We'll be flying to Barcelona on September 23rd; boarding the Emerald Princess for a 12-day Med cruise on the 26th; on October 8th we disembark in Venice and drive to Tuscany.
We'll be staying about 45 minutes south of Florence. We spent three days there on our last trip...certainly not enough time. From our base in Castellina in Chianti we'll drive to Florence, Siena, Pisa, Cinque Terra, San Gimignano, and others.
If anyone is interested in the name of the agency we are using, PM me and I'll be happy to provide contact info.
Lew