Is this a decent/good/bad trade?

[valeriesunshine]

I traded a VMK baby tee-shirt for a cowboy top with a vest.

 

[ShadowKittyKat]

If you and the person you traded with were both happy with what you got, then it was a good trade. In value - you got a better deal

 

[Pirate-Emery]

The Politically Correct thing to say: If you both enjoy the items, it was a good trade.

The Non-Politically Correct thing to say: OMG, did the other person just realize what they did?? You totally owned them in that trade!

 

[Maleficent2]

what is a baby t-shirt?

do you mean the baby doll top???

 

[ShadowKittyKat]

what is a baby t-shirt?

do you mean the baby doll top???

I'm sure that's what she meant... in any way, though, trading a t-shirt for a cowboy top... awesome!

 

[valeriesunshine]

Yeah sorry I meant baby doll top

 

[Pirate-Emery]

Yeah sorry I meant baby doll top

The one that is 25 credits?

 

[MissHaylie]

Whoah. GREAT trade

 

[Blumonkeyboy]

im sorry if this insults anyone but was that person drunk or nutty or inspector Cluesoe

 

[dancegrl1093]

im sorry if this insults anyone but was that person drunk or nutty or inspector Cluesoe

stole the words from my mouth. they must have been on drugs to make that trade (sorry if this offends anyone)!!! or did your signature say that you wanted one? because i made a trade like that (my trade was a little better than that though) to a girl who wanted a pirate hat. i wish people would just hand out stuff like that to me!!! did you tell them it was rare or something??? i just am in total shock!!!!

 

[VMK_KrazyLuke]

Yeah, if you both agrreed it's a good trade for both of you then. But really the person who wanted the baby doll top got the bad end of the deal because the cowboy vest is retired and the baby doll top is still available when creating a new character

 

[Maleficent2]

The person you traded with could have been gifting you and just took the shirt in trade as a good will gesture.


I do that all the time.


If I am in a room and someone asks about something nicely and if I have it on me, I will just gift them.

Funny thing is sometimes they close the trade window thinking it is a scam or something.

Mal

 

[dancegrl1093]

folks, i think this trade was unbelievable!!! i got:
2 penny presses (green)
a green turnstile
a purple operator's scoreboard
a skeleton at the helm
i think it was 3-5 blue crates
fireworks magic
HSM outfit

all for a pair of pink princess shoes!!!! in my opinion, it was worth it just for the fireworks magic, because i'm incredibly bad at it, but what's your opinion?

 

[LuvN~Travel]

Remind me to take you shopping sometimes. Great deal there!
Kim

 

[Dis-Wiz]

If you were happy after the trade, then it was a good deal!

 

[birdman94]

who is getting the better offer
im trade the in game quest pirate hat for the new pirate well plz tell me

 

[Someybody]

I think it's fair. If you want to loose a valuable pirate hat.

 

[birdman94]

why is pirate hats that rare and wells arent rare

 

[cat_herder]

who is getting the better offer
im trade the in game quest pirate hat for the new pirate well plz tell me

It depends, for each person it will be differnet.

I have one hat and no wells, but I wouldn't trade the hat for the well. I would wait a while and try to get the well with something else that I have several copies. But if you have several pirates hats, then trading one for the well be a great deal, since the well is so new.

On the other hand if you just went to WDW with your 20 brothers and sisters who don't play the game then they gave you their wells and you had no pirate hat, then you got the great deal.

In any trade, both people should feel they got good deal. If you are unhappy with the deal - don't trade.

 

[Briar__Rose]

A gold skirt bottom for either fireworks, invisibility, or teleportation magic. Which of those three are the most rare? I am in need of blue dress parts, so would it benefit me to hold onto my gold skirt bottom or to go through with the trade? Thanks for your thoughts!