We did the 2019 5-night West Coast Member's Cruise (San Diego to Vancouver) and enjoyed it. The cruise service, food, and staterooms are all the exact same excellent quality as a regular cruise. As PP has stated, you get a lot of "gifts", as in bringing an empty Army duffle bag with you to pack it all up and get it home. We met in person lots of other DVC members that I have only chatted with on this blog. And that was one of the best experiences during the 5-night cruise. Also, Disney brings in several guest speakers to talk about their job and experiences. We will do it again in the near future and bring the empty duffle bag. We arrived with only two roll-on luggage and left having to check the luggage and hand-carrying 4 beach-size totes (part of the gifts) stuffed to the brim.