I haven't stayed there yet, but I will be in Dec. so I'm reading up on it alot and here is what I've heard and what I think...
I have heard MOSTLY good reviews on the resort board. I have NOT heard many bad reviews on the Resorts board. The most common problems people had were :
Size
Noise, primarily water noise such as showers and toilets flushing
Parking
I think if you are looking for a larger resort room, to actually spend time in, PC is probably not your best bet. You probably would want to move up to a moderate.
Usually, by the time we get home, everyone else is sound asleep.

So noise is not a big concern. I've had noise issues at all kinds of hotels, from 5 star resorts all the way to motel 6 type places. But then, I've also had perfect silence at everywhere in between as well. I think it's really just the luck of the draw....
I have heard showers and toilets at almost every hotel I have ever stayed at, ever though. It's just what happens when you have tons of rooms working off the same system.
Parking won't be an issue if you don't have a car. We will, so this should be interesting since we usually stay at Pleasure Island until it closes. Though, we'll probably be using busses to get to and from PI. So hopefully we'll already be parked by then and then hop on a bus.
I picked Pop because we are only going for 6 days and we don't plan on spending much time in our rooms. We leave at 8 am and come home at 1 am. This was a quick trip because we couldn't wait a whole year and the price was right.
Keep in mind, I have seen about as many bad reviews of Poly Concierge as I have of Pop. So who knows.
Have a good trip, whatever you decide to do.
