We went to CR last year with our DD7, and it was one of her favorite dinners! Not because of the food (she had the pizza) but because of the Tank! Our ADR was for 5:20, we arrived at 5:00 and asked for a table near the tank, we were seated in about 10 minutes!
DH and I ordered the steak - it was the best steak of our entire trip (better than LeCellier!) I had the chocolate wave and DH ordered some almond dessert, DD got the make your own sundae with a Happy Birthday chocolate.
Mid way thourg dinner a sea turtle came right up to the glass next to DD and decided to take a nap! The turtle stayed there for the entire time that we were there. DD still talks about the "Turtle that came to Dinner"!
We had a great server, his name was Riley - he was the only server that I actually remembered from our trip - he was THAT good!
My DH says - "don't worry it's a Disney restaurant - there's something for everyone!"