Is it me or is American Idol....

[yourtravelpro]

...just not good anymore since Jennifer and George are now gone??

 

[lilboo]

Originally posted by yourtravelpro
...just not good anymore since Jennifer and George are now gone??

I've not watched this week...George is now GONE?

So it's LaToya, Jasmine, Diana and one more(?)...not much of a competition, IMO.

 

[yourtravelpro]

George was voted out last week.

This week it's LaToya, Jasmine, Diana and Fantasia. Boring!
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

 

[lilboo]

Oops, I guess I missed last week too.

George had such a positive and genuine personality...he'll be missed!

I don't care too much for Diana or Jasmine, I'm afraid. I'm surprised either of them made it this far, actually.

 

[bumcat]

I miss George...

 

[BabyLove99]

I totally agree! I loved George.

 

[Shel]

It was OK...typical, what you'd expect. I got into last season a whole lot more (CLAY!) than this year.

 

[ShuisFan584]

American Idol has been boring to me since John was voted off. I didn't really like George, but it has gotten even more boring, because it's now down to 4 girls who pretty much sound the same.

But then again, American Idol didn't start off on a good note this season because there was no Clay!!

 

[disykat]

I haven't enjoyed this season much either, nor have my kids. Last year we loved it and even went to the concert.

 

[calypso*a*go-go]

At this point I don't care who wins and have not voted for several weeks.

I miss George as well...his smile was infectious!

 

[Kitty 34]

I miss Clay and Ruben.

 

[dzneelvr]

This entire session has been a giant disappointment. The judges better bring a ton more energy to the selection process and get a more diverse and talented group for AI 3 or it will continue to go down the tubes. I think they are somewhat to blame for the marginally talented group.
You notice this session, Ryan doesn't mention the number of votes cast much--they're not breaking any phone-in numbers this round.
WDW ON JUNE 24

 

[meeshi]

Originally posted by dzneelvr
This entire session has been a giant disappointment. The judges better bring a ton more energy to the selection process and get a more diverse and talented group for AI 3 or it will continue to go down the tubes. I think they are somewhat to blame for the marginally talented group.
You notice this session, Ryan doesn't mention the number of votes cast much--they're not breaking any phone-in numbers this round.
WDW ON JUNE 24

I totally agree. I don't think this year's contestants even come close to the talent of last year's. I really don't care who wins and I won't be buying any CD's, that's for sure.

 

[helenabear]

I watched AI and AI2 religiously. I didn't watch AI3 for a bunch of reasons, mostly me thinking the voting isn't fair at all. I've seen a little bit of AI3 and truthfully it was a painful show to watch (hearing all the bad singing), so I am glad I didn't waste much time on it. If they have an AI4, they need to change something!!!

 

[poohtown]

Originally posted by helenabear
I watched AI and AI2 religiously. I didn't watch AI3 for a bunch of reasons, mostly me thinking the voting isn't fair at all. I've seen a little bit of AI3 and truthfully it was a painful show to watch (hearing all the bad singing), so I am glad I didn't waste much time on it. If they have an AI4, they need to change something!!!

i never watched #3. I figured no one would be as good as Clay and also like the poster above, I believe the voting isn't fair. Last season I tried for over two hours to vote for Clay and never got through. I decided to try Rubens line and got through right away and had my vote counted. I was so mad! Later I heard alot of people said they couldn't get through and even Clays mother never got to vote for him but Rubens mother voted a couple 100 times. If Clays line was constantly busy wouldn't you think that meant he was getting more votes.

 

[Sirius]

Fantasia! Fantasia! Fantasia!

 

[airhead]

FANTASIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[grinningghost]

As much as I loved George, I still enjoy the show.

 

[Micca]

 

[J.Cooper]

I miss George too. I was surprised he was voted off last week. I tried voting for him quite a few times, but his line was constantly busy? I was really shocked when he was voted off. Sometimes I think the voting is fixed!