Input needed on Blue Lagoon and/or Lucayan

[Rock'n Robin]

I really need to make this decision--I posted this before but hardly anyone responsed--anyone have feedback on the Blue Lagoon (we would do it with Stingray City but I'm more interested in BL) in Nassau or the lucayan beach day in Freeport? I need to choose.
Thanks!
Robin M.

 

[jel0511]

I posted to your previous post, but I'll post again. Stay on the ship and save your money. The beaches in the Bahamas aren't that GREAT, especially Blue Lagoon, a complete waste of money IMO. The ship will be empty and you'll have the pools to yourselves. Save the beach activities for Castaway Cay.

 

[aprilgail2]

We did the Lucayan Beach Day in Freeport and it was wonderful....they have a very large pool with a slide and you are feet from the beach so you could sit by the pool or the beach...it was a very fun day there!