I would go ahead and call disney. Make sure you have CRO (central reservations office) and not WDWT (Walt Disney World Travel Co). The travel company requires a larger deposit and has a horrible cancellation policy. W/ CRO you can cancel 5-days out from your vacation; but who would want to do that right.
Get your rates for your room first. It should be what I posted ( I think this was the message I replied to) or somewhat close to that. Then ask what the dining plan would cost. I think they give you one lump sum and don't break it down so you will have to break out your costs. You'll have to back out your room and park tickets to get what you will be paying for meals. I say you can eat counterservice for about $40 per meal. Kids meals are about $4-$6 each and I usually pay $10-$12 for an adult meal. If you get milk, they are huge and the kids can share, ice water is free!, get extra cups and split the huge sodas, and at the counter service in tomorrowland their chicken plate is out of this world for a counter service meal. Check out allears for menus and prices. If you want table service meals each day, then I say you probably want to consider the dining plan (I have never used it so I can't give you much input on it). If you will be mostly counter service then you may want to book a room only and get your tickets from a broker (mousesavers has some recommendations). If you will return to the Allstar for breaks, then you would not want to get the meal plan unless it can be used at the food courts.
Also, I think the POP is considered a value resort just like the AllStars.
Get your rates for your room first. It should be what I posted ( I think this was the message I replied to) or somewhat close to that. Then ask what the dining plan would cost. I think they give you one lump sum and don't break it down so you will have to break out your costs. You'll have to back out your room and park tickets to get what you will be paying for meals. I say you can eat counterservice for about $40 per meal. Kids meals are about $4-$6 each and I usually pay $10-$12 for an adult meal. If you get milk, they are huge and the kids can share, ice water is free!, get extra cups and split the huge sodas, and at the counter service in tomorrowland their chicken plate is out of this world for a counter service meal. Check out allears for menus and prices. If you want table service meals each day, then I say you probably want to consider the dining plan (I have never used it so I can't give you much input on it). If you will be mostly counter service then you may want to book a room only and get your tickets from a broker (mousesavers has some recommendations). If you will return to the Allstar for breaks, then you would not want to get the meal plan unless it can be used at the food courts.
Also, I think the POP is considered a value resort just like the AllStars.