I'm stumped! Help me choose...

[PrincessV]

I'm down to one dinner for which I need a restaurant. Party is me, DS4 and my mother, 60. I've narrowed it down to this group:
Cape May Cafe
Spoodles
Yacht Club Galley

All menus have something we can all eat, so I guess it's mostly down to ambience and food quality. What do you think?

 

[marksor]

With a four-year old I would opt for the Cape May buffet. There is plenty of kid-friendly food. Yacht Club is going to be an older, steak-eating crowd. Spoodles will pretty much have a Mickey pizza for little kids and the atmosphere is not as kid-friendly as Cape May.

 

[tracys2cents]

HA! I had the exact same dilemma about 5 hours ago! Cape May wasn't available so the girl on the phone recommended Spoodles. Her FAVORITE disney restaurant and she frequents them all. Told me to get the flatbread appetizer, a steak or the salmon or the seafood stew (her favorite is the steak)...and told us to ask our waiter (right away before ordering) to save us a "dessert platter" because they run out . It's a platter of all their desserts in mini-sizes.

We're on the dining plan so I didn't ask about prices.

I'm glad i picked spoodles because I just read another thread with lots of thumbs down about Cape may, and a review of Yacht Galley that called it a glorified Denny's.