We did a Wishes cruise earlier this month and we were very pleased. We had music piped in. Yes, you were not "right there" but we were centered enough to see tink fly. We had a tour of Bay lake and 7 Seas Lagoon with lots of information given. Best of all, we arrived back at WL and no crowds to fight getting back to our rooms.
There are snacks and water, pop provided in the cost. We bought chocolate covered strawberries and wine from room service to enjoy on board. We would do it again.
We usually watch Illuminatations from the bridge between UK and France, and all of the boats for the Illuminations cruises gather there. It looks so crowded and that's why we didn't go for one of those. It seemed that we were alone watching Wishes, even though there were other boats around, just not right there next to us.
Bobbi