I was on the fence about this a while back, but have finally chosen Citrico's. Why? Well, looking at the pictures of both restaurants, Citrico's just looks so beautiful! Both places seem to have their fans, so I went more for atmosphere, as we will be celebrating DH's birthday. We will have the kids with us, but they are older and have wonderful restaurant behavior.
BTW - I am also a nice blue eyed woman from MA!!! Enjoy your vacation!