We've been twice and although the meal and ambiance is fantastic, I just don't think the upcharge is worth it when we are already spending so much on the cruise itself. The $75/person fee was acceptable in 2016 but I just can't justify the now $125/person upcharge when we went this past July. Both times we went on Pirate Night since we think the menu in the MDR that night is meh and I won't go near the night time buffet or fireworks. In 2016 there were about 10 couples. I think I counted maybe 4 tops at any given time during our meal this last trip. Maybe the higher cost affected the attendance, maybe not? Anyways--$350 later and my wife and I decided that this money will go towards more spa treatments on future cruises. We've also been to V & A twice and have always thought that those experiences have been better than Remy's which is interesting since the American menu option is inspired by the same chef as V & A. Although the head chef may have changed since we were last there. It's been a while. Sorry for the rambling LOL! Does anyone else feel the same way?