I need help deciding if I should wear a birthday pin on my trip?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Besides Disney celebrates their B-days for a year and a half.

Hahaha. Good point!

Still though, I'd be afraid that there would be lines out the door at City Hall with people waiting for birthday pins so that they could get 'free stuff.'
I think it'd get to the point where CMs would just ignore them because everyone would be wearing them.

I'm not judging anyone, just thinking that the days of special birthday treatment may be numbered.
 
Hahaha. Good point!

Still though, I'd be afraid that there would be lines out the door at City Hall with people waiting for birthday pins so that they could get 'free stuff.'
I think it'd get to the point where CMs would just ignore them because everyone would be wearing them.

I'm not judging anyone, just thinking that the days of special birthday treatment may be numbered.

What free stuff?

I'll give you the fact that I've only worn one at Disneyland, not world, but I got nothing free other than the button. Just lots of smiles and well-wishes. But nothing free that would otherwise have been charged for. :)
 
Well, I was VERY LUCKY to be at Disney on my birthday/Dec as a surprise gift from my hubby (who just humors me with our yearly spring or summer trip since it's not really his thing) BUT HE HAS SO MANY OTHER GOOD QUALITIES LOL:lmao:
I digress....We were only there for a quick weekend, literally flew in Fri morning and left Sunday afternoon, and was given the Birthday pin at check in at AKL (my husband told them it was my b/day).
Well, first we got upgraded for the room....LOVELY Savannah view
Then at MK I was given a free dessert, very surprised and Yummy!
All day long I was given well wishes and it was truly a Magical day I will not soon forget....Oh, the piano player at MK even sang H/Birthday too!
Well, I say if its your birthday celebration trip, wear a pin. Don't expect anything, I certainly didn't have any idea of the pin or what "magic" it would bring and was very pleasantly surprised!

HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU AND HAVE A MAGICAL TIME!!!pixiedust: party: :bday:
 
I agree with the not doing it crowd. Personally I wouldn't wear a birthday button unless it was the day of my birthday.



Six months after your birthday? Geeze why even have birthday buttons if you can wear them any time of the year.

Because its the only time I have to take time off from my job and celebrate my birthday and my anniversary. I am so sorry if this upsets you so much. Plus this is DISNEY where Dreams COME TRUE!!! Just like you can become a kid again.
 
I don't know what I think about the subject. I think if it's really far off, then it's perhaps not appropriate. If it's wihtin a short enough period of time to be reasonable...but then who defines reasonable.

I've never been. I get to go for the first time in September and who knows if I'll ever be lucky enough to go for my REAL birthday. However, my compromise was this. I will be there on September 9th, exactly 1 month before my birthday. I requested a "A Very Merry Unbirthday to Me!" Alice in Wonderland design from the DIS creative board and will sport my unbirthday shirt and have my own unbirthday sort of happiness on that day. I am not planning on getting a birthday button nor will it be on our ressies.

Hopefully I'll be able to go someday for my birthday on my actual birthday and I can't wait to wear a pin when that happens! (if they're still doing it then!)
 
Ah the great old debate of if it's ok to wear the birthday button or pin at WDW when it's not your birthday.

My opinion is wear it and have a great time no matter if others here are trying to make you feel guilty. The OP never stated that she wanted to get anything free by wearing the pin and if she got a free Mickey Ice Cream Bar or a Cupcake, the world is not going to end. Besides not everyone is able to celebrate their birthday when it actually happens and if they celebrate it later on, it does not effect me or anyone else. If WDW really cared wouldn't they ask for ID when handing out the buttons or pins when someone asks for them?
 
i'm sorry but i'm with the crowd of no. if it was a day or two off, or maybe even a week. but months....no, i'm sorry. yes you may be "celebrating" your birthday, but it's not your actual birthday. go ahead and get the pin, who cares, but i wouldn't wear it.

a lot of people talk about all the special treatment they get with the pins. if it were me, i'd feel really bad if something really special happened to me when it wasn't my birthday, and nothing happened for someone else when it really was their birthday.

if you want to celebrate something, more power to ya. make t-shirts saying something about finally celebrating the big day with the date on it. cm's will still say congratulations/happy birthday to you.
 
I agree that people should do whatever they feel is right. But I'm not getting one for out trip 13 days after my birthday. DS is having his birthday on the trip and will get a button to wear a few days. My DD will not be getting a button- her birthday is 3 months before the trip because it does take away from the people actually having birthdays. BTW- If you aren't hoping for extra "magic" why would you wear the pin at all especially months away from your actual b-day?:confused3
 
Am I the only one that thinks this isn't right?

SnwflkCts, BillSears, rolshuk think you are right and ChefBilly and abbybeth are on the fence.

However, as of 9:01pm (EST), TwinsandQuads, bumbershoot,Tinkerbell63,Tinks Girls,ferfer76,Luv Bunnies,Poohbear67, autumnbaby9, kmjmom, MomofCKJ, autumnbaby9, bumbershoot, a1tinkfans, CR Resort Fan 4 Life, crzyred, Tricialiv and digitaltim apparently think it is alright. Bravo Zulu to you.

Does that answer your question?
 
Some of us never expect to get anything. I see that we have over looked the fact that my dbf will be celebrating his birthday there so I want to share with him so we deceided to do this together and just have fun and go with it not to get anything.

Before making I guess judgments about people and why they should or should not do things maybe there is a reason they want or need to do this.
Maybe in there life they had some very special happen to them and never got to spend it with there FATHER maybe.

I have a thread on the Thank you boards if anyone is interested in reading maybe this will help you understand why I LOVE DISNEY so much and why I would love to celebrate my birthday there, its was a thank you to Cinderalla.

Again I am sorry if this bothers anyone, I really don't mean for this to be such a mess. I am a very nice person and I feel like alot of people are very upset with me and I am genuinely hurt.
:sad1:
 
Don't apologize! I, for one, am sorry that the postings have made you feel bad. We all have different reasons for the choices that we make and that's when we need to trust our own decisions and NOT worry about what others think. Have a wonderful trip spent the way that makes you feel best!!:hug:
 
Don't apologize! I, for one, am sorry that the postings have made you feel bad. We all have different reasons for the choices that we make and that's when we need to trust our own decisions and NOT worry about what others think. Have a wonderful trip spent the way that makes you feel best!!:hug:

Thank you so much for being so nice and understanding!!:hug:

here is the thread I was talking about, please read it and let me know if you understand why I feel the way I do.

http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=1459232
 
My DGF has her birthday in July and we are going in August to celebrate it. Both of us are in college/internships during the summer and we can only get off the last two weeks in August to do anything. Im getting her the pin because I paid alot of money for this vacation and there is nothing wrong in wearing it. We did the same thing last year and we didnt get anything except for a few "how old are you?". There is nothing morally wrong in wearing it if your doing it to celebrate. If your getting the pin for free stuff, then yea it would be wrong.
 
I think it's wrong to do this.

HOWEVER, I think it's ok to wear it for an entire trip....IF you have a birthday sometime during your length of stay. We're leaving on the 6th to celebrate DD's birthday (which is the 6th). I'm gonna let her wear the b-day button for the entire 4 days that we're there.

If it's not your birthday, it's not your birthday.
Wouldn't you feel weird deceiving people when they say 'Happy Birthday' when you know it's really not? I would.
 
Oh Nancy Ann,
I couldn't make it all the way through your tender story without crying. I lost my Dad too and I know how certain places and words touch your heart so deeply. Please do not let let other people's opinions sway you from your hearts choice!!:woohoo:
 
Oh Nancy Ann,
I couldn't make it all the way through your tender story without crying. I lost my Dad too and I know how certain places and words touch your heart so deeply. Please do not let let other people's opinions sway you from your hearts choice!!:woohoo:

Thank you,

:hug:
 
wear the button...its all good.

as long as you don't wear your birthday suite
 
Some of us never expect to get anything. I see that we have over looked the fact that my dbf will be celebrating his birthday there so I want to share with him so we deceided to do this together and just have fun and go with it not to get anything.

Before making I guess judgments about people and why they should or should not do things maybe there is a reason they want or need to do this.
Maybe in there life they had some very special happen to them and never got to spend it with there FATHER maybe.

I have a thread on the Thank you boards if anyone is interested in reading maybe this will help you understand why I LOVE DISNEY so much and why I would love to celebrate my birthday there, its was a thank you to Cinderalla.

Again I am sorry if this bothers anyone, I really don't mean for this to be such a mess. I am a very nice person and I feel like alot of people are very upset with me and I am genuinely hurt.
:sad1:

maybe i missed something but i don't believe anyone was personally attacking you. some are simply saying that we don't feel it would be right. we however can not stop you from doing anything. do whatever you want, who cares, it's your choice.

i am sorry for your story.:hug:
 
here is the thread I was talking about, please read it and let me know if you understand why I feel the way I do.

http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=1459232

I do understand why you love the magic of Disney World. I miss my Dad too and never got to experience WDW with him. But sorry that still doesn't explain why pretending it's your birthday 6 months after your real birthday is ok.

As others have said no one is going to stop you from doing it. But when people ask our opinions on a subject we should be able to respond to it.

Have a great trip and I hope you get to visit Cinderella again soon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom