Take the Dolphin at $129 plus 10% off. That is a fantastic rate -- cheaper than the rates the PP listed for a value. Dolphin is a deluxe resort with a fantastic location and good bus service to MK. While it may not have the big Disney icons, it has so much more to offer in terms of rooms, bedding, service plus a wonderful pool with waterfall, slide and hot tubs.
I would never consider a value when that rate at the Dolphin is available. We have stayed at the Dolphin and it is great. Lots of dining options -- including the Fountain, which is fun for kids. While it is more "grown-up" than the values, there is a Disney souvenir shop and boats to two Disney parks.
Take the Dolphin and don't look back!