how to cook a turkey?

PaDisney02

DIS Veteran
Joined
Mar 24, 2008
Messages
510
I'm doing thanksgiving this year for my inlaws! I've never cooked a turkey b4. My parents turkey is always very good, but not very juicy. One year we went to my husbands aunt's house and her turkey was the best I have ever had. Her turkey was SO juicy. Does any1 have any tips for me on how to make the perfect turkey? Thanks
 
A whole lot of work... but Google "Thompson's Turkey". :thumbsup2

or go fry one..... very easy to do.
 
I always cook our turkey in one of those special oven bags. Juicy every time!! :)
 
We rub butter all over the turkey(including the area between the skin and meat on the top of the turkey). Then we put the turkey in the pan with celery,onions,poultry seasoning,salt,pepper and wine.
When we put the turkey in the oven,we start the gravy(onions,celery,wine,poultry seasoning,salt,pepper and the giblets),then every 30 minutes or so we baste the turkey with the gravy juices.Then when the turkey is done we baste him one more time and let the turkey stand for 15 minutes(so the juices have time to rest in the meat).
If the turkey is browning too quickly cover with aluminum foil- don't put the foil on tight just drape it over the bird.
 

DH follows the directions to Alton Brown's Good Eats turkey, and it is consistently excellent. Just don't put the probe thermometer into the turkey until AFTER the heat blast - do it when you put on the turkey triangle. Good flavor, perfectly moist, white meat cooked, dark meat not overcooked. We bought a cheap 5 gallon water cooler from Home Depot and it is the turkey bath - we put the bird, brine and ice in it and then set it outside, closed up.
 
First, be sure to take the bag of "stuff" out of it. My sister cooked her first turkey not knowing it was in there. :lmao: How do you not know? Don't you wash out the inside before cooking? :lmao:
 
Go buy the Reynolds bags (turkey size) and they have the directions in the package. You get a nice moist turkey and no basting required.
 
Why don't you just call your husband's aunt and ask her how she does her turkey? She would probably be pleased that you remembered how good it was and happy to help out a first timer.

Sometimes I use an oven bag, but I found they make the bottom of the turkey soggy, and there is so much fat in the bag that it made the gravy really greasy. I stopped using them about 2 years ago, and now I just roast the turkey at about 325, for 20 mins per pound. I stuff the turkey with bread crumbs, onion, butter, salt, pepper and savory. I baste it every now and again and it turn out good. The important thing is to let the turkey "rest" after you take it out of the oven. Just leave it covered with foil for at least 15 mins-30 mins to let the juices "set" before you carve it. Gives the meat a chance to re-absorb the juices that were brought to the surface during the cooking.
 
I brine, too. And we cook a wild turkey every year, so we have to work extra hard to get it moist (no fat on the turkey). I thaw it in a cooler with ice water, salt, cajun seasoning, and an onion. Before putting it in the browning bag, I coat it with butter and layer it with bacon. Delicious every time! Dh even got hunting rights to his boss's land after we fed her one year. All I have to do in exchange is cook her some turkey!
 
First, be sure to take the bag of "stuff" out of it. My sister cooked her first turkey not knowing it was in there. :lmao: How do you not know? Don't you wash out the inside before cooking? :lmao:

There is a bag of 'stuff' at both ends too :thumbsup2 .
 
Another vote for Alton Brown's method. We made it last time and not one piece of turkey was left at the end of dinner. :thumbsup2
 
DH follows the directions to Alton Brown's Good Eats turkey, and it is consistently excellent.

We brine ours- VERY moist.

Yep, this is what we do, too. DH has done the brine thing every year since we got married - I thought it was weird at first, but you just can't argue with the results.

Before you cook the bird, stuff the cavity with some onions (quartered), a couple lemons (also quartered), several whole cloves of garlic (peeled), and a bunch of fresh herbs (rosemary, thyme, whatever you like). This will help flavor the meat, and then when your done roasting it adds tons of flavor to the drippings for some excellent gravy.
 
My first turkey I just followed the directions on the bird and it was awesome. Now I soak it in salt water for about 12 - 24 hours before cooking. I don't put as much salt as a brine but just enough to make it extra juicy and add soem flavor.
 
Go buy the Reynolds bags (turkey size) and they have the directions in the package. You get a nice moist turkey and no basting required.

This bag has always made for a hassle free and excellent turkey. I use it every year and highly recommend it.

However... for all the tips & tricks (plus some lame but endearing humor) I link you to our dear Alton Brown of "Good Eats" Food Network fame.

This episode: "Romancing the Bird".

I started with part two of the four part episode... part one contains only history and quaint but lame humor. You'll find parts 3 & 4 to the right.
 
15- pound Turkey, thawed, giblets and neck removed (do not use pre-basted)
2 pounds kosher salt
2 gallons cold water or apple juice
2 cups brown sugar
½ cup dried rosemary leaves (not crushed)
½ cup dried thyme leaves (not crushed)
1-onion peeled and quartered
1 carrot peeled and cut into 1 inch chunks
1 small stalk celery cut into 1 inch chunks
1 apple peeled, cored and quartered
Unsalted butter melted
Marsala Wine (optional)


Rinse turkey in cool water. In a very large container, mix salt and water together until salt dissolves. Stir in brown sugar and spices. Mix well until sugar dissolves. Totally submerge poultry in solution and store covered in refrigerator for 8-12 hours. (There is no need to stir the brine or shift the turkey unless the brine does not cover all parts of the turkey. If this is the case, turn the turkey every few hours to make sure each part is submerged at some point.)

Remove turkey from brine. Discard brine. Thoroughly rinse turkey under a slow stream of cool water, rubbing gently to release salt, both inside and out. Pat skin and both interior cavities dry with a paper towel. In the cavity of the turkey, place onion, carrot, celery, and apple. Brush turkey with melted butter.

Preheat oven to 325 degrees F. Place turkey, breast side down, on a V rack, in a shallow roasting pan. Then scatter in a couple of sliced onions, a chopped carrot or two, a couple of stalks of chopped celery, and a sprig or two of fresh thyme (lemon thyme adds a nice touch) and about a cup of white wine or water. During this time, continuously baste legs and back with melted butter. If needed, cover with aluminum foil to avoid the turkey getting too brown. About 1 ½ hours, before the turkey is done, remove turkey from oven and protecting your hands, grasp turkey with several layers of clean paper towels at both ends, and turn turkey, breast side up. Soak cheesecloth with melted butter and wine and place over the breast. Return turkey to oven and continue to roast, basting with pan drippings and/or butter and wine mixture through the cheesecloth. About ½ hour before turkey is done remove the cheesecloth until internal temperature reaches 170 degrees F. Remove turkey from the oven and allow it to stand for 20 minutes. Remove vegetables from cavity and discard before carving.

*Added Touches*
Herbs: other combinations of herbs may be added including, honey, molasses, maple syrup, fruit juices (I use apple juice), beer, booze, pickling spices, cloves, garlic, citrus fruits, bay leaves, black peppercorns, and other herbs and spices. A spicy flavor may be achieved by the addition of 1-cup small dried red chili peppers. Many recipes call for bring the ingredients to a boil to dissolve the sugars and bring out the flavor of the herbs, then cooling the mixture to 40 degrees F before using the flavored brine.

Basting: half melted butter and half Marsala Wine mixture (or other good cooking wine)

The pan juices that result make for wonderful gravy. Do not add any salt until you have tasted everything. You probably will not need any. The same is true for the sliced turkey meat you serve. Tell your guest to taste the meat before they salt it.

Bon Appetite
 
Why don't you just call your husband's aunt and ask her how she does her turkey? She would probably be pleased that you remembered how good it was and happy to help out a first timer.

I wish I could...my husbands family does not really speak English to good. Plus, they live far way and really dont even know us so they porbably wont even give me the time of day!

I do however remeber some1 saying that they had to get up in the middle of the night to start the turkey. Has any1 ever had a turkey that was cooked for a long period of time? My parents always cook it for 3-4 hours. I think this lady cooked her turkey for 12 hours or so. What temp would I cook it at if I kept it in for 12 hour? Thanks
 
The Butterball Turkey website offers some nice pointers that you may want to point out.

The big things - make sure to allow it enough time to thaw. Grab the "bags of goodies" from both ends.

We buy a fresh turkey, so no thawing is necessary, but even still, they advise us to let it sit in the fridge for a day or two.

We do not stuff our bird, we don't put anything in the cavity...although after reading some previous poster's ideas, maybe we will this year.
 
I'm doing thanksgiving this year for my inlaws! I've never cooked a turkey b4. My parents turkey is always very good, but not very juicy. One year we went to my husbands aunt's house and her turkey was the best I have ever had. Her turkey was SO juicy. Does any1 have any tips for me on how to make the perfect turkey? Thanks

Before deep frying I would place bacon over the Turkey and use a Brown N Bag for Turkey size. This keeps things juicy and crisp skin from the bacon. this is a fool proof way. The timeing per pound is on the bag. You put a tbls flour in the bag shake, place in the bag, make the slits and time. There will be juice for gravy in the bag, or for a cassarole the days to come.
Di

Edited to add, don;t forget to defrost the Turkey. I do mine in the fridge two days before. For cooking time, if you use the brown n bag for turkeys, it will tell you how long per lb. Keep the tag that has the weight on it. This is really a fool proof way to make the bird for a novice.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer

New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom