I'll tell you this. If you want to be immersed in the experience CAT 1 or II is the only way you go. The players get off the stage and walk around you and it feels like you are part of the show. If you are on the balcony then you are just watching. Sometimes the cast goes upstairs but only for a fleeting moment and you don't really feel like a part of the show. This is my own opinion but the CAT I seating is WAY worth it.