Been twice, and it has been great both times. We were in #1 seating the first time and #2 this time. Our first table was just off the stage, this week's table was on the floor, very back and dead center of the entry doors. From anywhere on the floor you can see the show without difficulty. I haven't been on balcony seats before, but you can request the other two sections to avoid it.
It is the best dinner show Disney offers, and one of the best dinner shows I've seen in all my vacations to various places in the South. I did notice some of the songs were different this time than in 2012, so it added a new element for us. Granted, it is expensive, but worth it to me, especially if not seen before.
I don't do the dining plan, since most of the food at most of the restaurants is the same now adays since dining plan took away the uniqueness that different restaurants used to offer. Hoop is different, I haven't found this taste of rib, chicken, corn, or beans anywhere else on property.
Well worth it for a first timer, and if you don't agree, just match your next vacation up with mine and I'll cook ya dinner to make up for it.