disneymom3 said:
Lisa--do you think you could teach the Scaredy Cat system with just the student book or do you need the whole package? I am really intrigued by this system. I have heard Joyce Herzog speak and was totally impressed with all she said. I just worry that $50 is a bit to spend when who knows if my 5 yo will just pick it up on his own like his sister did. However, he is definitely not ready to do the writing that so many programs require at beginnning reading so that is another thing that draws me to this.
Feedback, feedback.....
I do recommend the package. The CD has the songs and lessons--and the flash cards are great. As well as games. It is all rather pedestrian in quality--and one could make them at home...but for me to tell you how would be a breach of her copyright

and that is what you are paying for with her. The teacher manual also lists an approach to teaching it to get the stuff in their minds. (which is what I needed). The package includes: Teacher manual and student workbook (plastic spiral-bounded), flashcards (words for each vowel, rebel words, upper and lower case alphabet--must cut yourself though

), On letter-size card stock: games for each vowel, upper case alphabet, lower case alphabet, vowels in different fonts, and on a double laminate sheet a game which I think encompasses all the words learned in the set. Additionally---a little dime set of game pawns and a pair of dice.
It has no writing as a requirement--but it is an option--as DD5 is mastering words--instead of just having her spell them out loud--I am having her write them to practice penmanship. If they are writing they can write--if not, they don't have to. Part of it is learning to spell the words--but they can speak that instead of writing it. The program was initially geared towards LD students that Ms. Herzog taught--and her priority is on teaching kids how to read...even those deemed unteachable. ETA: She later made it available to homeschoolers---and I didn't mean to convey that our kids are teachable--just that this is a user friendly program to teach phonics/reading.
Glancing at the workbook--you could use alone--but I need all the other materials to make it easier for me to convey the material. If workbooks is all you need--you can get workbooks anywhere. Joyce's stuff---to me it is the songs that sell it for me. Not that I enjoy her singing voice (about as bad as mine

)--but the songs are catchy and that is what my daughter is picking up. She has songs for ALL the phonics rules pertinent. I do have the CD from level 1 which is just the songs. Level 2--the CD is sectioned into lessons and songs are within the lesson, no way to call up just the songs.
We "wasted" our money on level 1--but I am glad to have the CD. I say wasted...b/c we got it and started it--finished maybe 10 letters. Took a break in May--then when we started school....for a kick, I gave her the letter sounds test--and she practically aced it (missed 1 b/c of confusion--not lack of knowing the sound). So between getting it and really getting down to using it--she figured out all the sounds. So I had to quickly buy level 2 and that is what we are using now.
If your child already knows sounds--skip level 1 and go to level 2. If you can get the songs CD--I would get that as well.
Also--please note--these aren't going to be the fancy workbooks like explode the code (binded--profesional printing)--it is obvious (to me) that they are...in lieu of a better word...homemade/printed professionally. They are well-made...but I can tell it is a homemade effort. The material is good though and daughter enjoys it. I did buy one supplement item, but did not like it. I am going to stick to the meat of her stuff--and not get the extra stuff (her booklets and such).
Hope this helps--ultimately, you have to get what you will think worked for you. DD was getting so bored with Explode the Code and we weren't really getting anywhere. She wanted to learn to read--and I couldn't keep her interested in learning what she needed to in Get, Ready, Set--she wanted to jump right in--and the material was too hard for her. She enjoys the scaredy cat (though today--she didn't like her 3 new words..my mistake on the ones I picked

).
ETA: Just put the wkbk away and took another peak--there are pages that say "instructions in teacher's manual". Also I recall reading in her instructions that the workbook isn't meant to be used alone (hence the reference for instructions). Just an additional FYI for you.