Praise2Him
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2000
- Messages
- 2,991
Here's my 2 cents worth...
Re: skipping books - I know that when I was in school (many years ago
) I was terrible in math, so while most students went from 8th grade math to Algebra 1 in 9th grade, the rest of us had to take 9th grade math, then go to Algebra in 10th grade.
Fast forward to the present: My DD was in a private Christian school in 7th grade and used Saxon 76. They skipped to Algebra 1/2 the next year. I was told that Saxon 87 was for those students (like me) who struggled with basic math and needed some more help before going on to Algebra.
Maybe you can do some research and find out if that's true, but it makes sense to me.
Re: Saxon vs TT - our first year to homeschool DD was in 8th grade and as mentioned above had used Saxon in 7th, so we continued with that (Algebra 1/2). We had major problems with it, because, also as mentioned above, I'm not good in math, so I couldn't understand it to teach it to her. Fortunately she loves math, so we struggled through it, but she had to get most of it on her own, with help from DH (also an engineer
).
That's the main reason we switched to TT - because it was developed by homeschooling parents and was designed to be pretty much self-taught. It's worked wonderfully for us, but if you're happy with Saxon and it's working well for you I don't see any reason to change.
Re: skipping books - I know that when I was in school (many years ago

Fast forward to the present: My DD was in a private Christian school in 7th grade and used Saxon 76. They skipped to Algebra 1/2 the next year. I was told that Saxon 87 was for those students (like me) who struggled with basic math and needed some more help before going on to Algebra.
Maybe you can do some research and find out if that's true, but it makes sense to me.
Re: Saxon vs TT - our first year to homeschool DD was in 8th grade and as mentioned above had used Saxon in 7th, so we continued with that (Algebra 1/2). We had major problems with it, because, also as mentioned above, I'm not good in math, so I couldn't understand it to teach it to her. Fortunately she loves math, so we struggled through it, but she had to get most of it on her own, with help from DH (also an engineer

That's the main reason we switched to TT - because it was developed by homeschooling parents and was designed to be pretty much self-taught. It's worked wonderfully for us, but if you're happy with Saxon and it's working well for you I don't see any reason to change.