I've been wondering the same darn thing!!! I think I have a good idea of where to go for our other park days, but this one is a stumper!!!!
We tried H&V, thought it was okay, but it normally gets awful reviews.
Next we tried Sci-Fi, once was more than enough there for me.
What's left...Mama Melrose (you liked it, but we're already eating Italian elsewhere)...50's Prime Time Cafe...Hollywood Brown Derby (2 TS)
Any other TS I'm not thinking of???
OP, I had a great idea (IMHO) of taking the boat from HS to the Beach Club resort to eat at Cape May Cafe, but we consider Fantasmic! a must-see, and if we wait till after, it'll be too late for us. Maybe it would work for you? There's another thread on the 1st page talking about it right now, and it looks/sounds AWESOME!!!
Best of luck to both of us!!