Ok, this freaked me out as I carefully planned my ADRs to avoid the affected restaurants during the November holiday surcharge period, so I called Disney Dining. Spoke with CM Barbara in Dining......according to her computer the dates for holiday dining surcharges in Nov/December are Nov 22-29 and December 16 to January 3. She shows nothing else before the end of the year (the summer holiday charges have ended, and the next block she had was April something).
I told her that a "friend" had just told me that they were making reservations for December 1st to 14th and were told they'd be under the holiday surcharge.
She apologized, and requested that I have my "friend" call back to verify that the CM had made the reservations for the correct days. She said that the holiday surcharge notice comes up on as one of the instructions they have to provide (other examples she gave me of instructions are the "ticket to the park required" and the "non-smoking restaurant" and "characters are not guaranteed"), so the only reason that a CM would have told my "friend" this was because it was booked on an incorrect date. She again apologized and said that this type of error does happen and would I please encourage my "friend" to call in and check on it.
I had her verify ALL my ADRs during the first two weeks of December and the holiday surcharge did not come up on ANY of them. These are the places I have ADRs that don't come up with a holiday surcharge (I know some of them aren't on the holiday surcharge list of participating restaurants, but I wanted her to check ALL of them to be sure I'd have no surprises):
December 1: Biergarten
December 2: 1900 Park Fare dinner
December 3: 50's lunch and Sci Fi dinner
December 4: Garden Grill dinner
December 5: Tusker breakfast
December 6: GF tea
December 7: O'Hanas dinner
December 8: Boma breakfast
December 9: Cinderella's Royal Table breakfast
December 10: Cape May/Goofy breakfast
December 11: Marrakesh lunch, Coral Reef dinner
December 12: 1900 Park Fare breakfast
December 13: Liberty Tree character dinner
So....as requested, I encourage wdwquilt to call and verify that their dates are correct.