Help!! What would you do with the $3k check?

Mom2Satan&Daisy

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jul 2, 2007
Messages
542
If someone gave you three thousand dollars, would you take it?

It's a pretty long story, but the backstory is important in this case, so here I go.

After the hurricane 5 years ago, my neighbors moved out. The house was messed up. About a year ago, I got new neighbors. These people apparently have plenty of money, as they bought a hurricane house and fixed it up quite nicely, all for the waterfront view.

They do not live here. This is their weekend home. They come for a few days about once a month. They are extremely nice people.

We've done them a few favors in the past. We keep an eye on the house. We have keys to their house. We let in the phone guy, dealt with the state trooper showing up three times in three days because the phone lines got wet and it was somehow triggering 911 calls from the house, they had a new well drilled and we dealt with the well people for them, since we're here and they aren't, we called to let them know their house got struck by lightning, we checked it out to make sure that the house was ok, we just keep an eye out for them, and keep them in the know about things going on.

A few weeks ago, they were down for their weekend visit, and they came over to talk like they always do. They brought us a card, and inside was a Lowes gift card for $250. We didn't want to take it, but they insisted, as a thanks for all the things we do for them (which to me, doesn't amount to much, it's just neighborly).

We got to talking about the well. Like I said, they just had a new well drilled not too long ago. And ever since they drilled their well, our well has gone bad. So they asked about our water situation. We told them how it was, the water is funky and it's made life difficult, but we're getting a new well drilled this coming Monday, blah blah blah.

Now here's where it gets tricky. I've posted about the well problems we've had. I've also talked to well drillers, including the one that drilled their well. While it's unlikely that them drilling a well caused problems for our well, it is possible. But there's no way to know for sure.

And they're so nice, that they actually called around and asked some people the same question, and got the same result. Probably not, but possible.

So now they feel guilty. And they're really nice people.

A couple of days later, the guy called and spoke with my husband. He TOLD my husband he was sending a check for half the cost of the well. (He knows how much they are because he just put one in.) My husband told him no, absolutely not. The guy says he WANTS to, he feels bad. My husband tells him that it's not their fault, don't worry about it. They guy says for hubby to think of it as a Christmas present. Hubby says that's too much for a Christmas present, thanks but no thanks. The guy says he's sending it anyway.

So the three thousand dollar check came in the mail today. I seriously just want to put it in an envelope, thank them for their graciousness, but decline. Hubby says that he told the guy he was going to mail it back when he talked to the guy the other day, and the guy said he'd just remail it again.

What the hell do I do?
 
you take the check graciously and continue being a good neighbor. you are doing a lot for them by just watching over one of their biggest assets. you both obviously deserve it, talk about good karma!
 
you take the check graciously and continue being a good neighbor. you are doing a lot for them by just watching over one of their biggest assets. you both obviously deserve it, talk about good karma!

Excellent advice. :) The fact is, they would probably pay a lot more than that for a property management company to do the same things you do for free as a good neighbor.
 
Keep it. YOu are doing them a HUGE favor!
 

you take the check graciously and continue being a good neighbor. you are doing a lot for them by just watching over one of their biggest assets. you both obviously deserve it, talk about good karma!
I agree. What a nice thank-you!! You guys are obviously wonderful neighbors!! Care to move next door to me??:goodvibes
 
I can see both sides here. If you are really uncomfortable about keeping the money and using it for the well, why not use it for a charity? That would buy a lot of food for the local food pantry at a time they really need it. Or a lot of Angel Tree presents for some local kids.

Then you can send them a Christmas card that says "A donation has been made in your name to XYZ organization". Just don't mention how much;)

ETA: OP your avatar freaked the heck out of me!!! I thought maybe I had some all new mod powers that I didn't know about before!!!:rotfl:
 
Don' send it back. Cash it and if you are not comfortable keeping it then donate it. I'm sure there are a lot of local charities that could use some funds right now. Food banks usually hurt for donations during the holidays and it seems like more and more people need to use them right now.
 
If you are too uncomfortable to keep it, I love the idea of donating it to charity. But I definitely think you should graciously accept it. Lucky you, you get the chance to 'pay it forward'!:goodvibes
 
I agree with Sayla and Nancy if you feel uncomfortable donate it to charity.


I think you should graciously accept it. While it's a nice thought to donate it, I think it would be insulting them to do this. You've given them plenty of opportunity to back out of this, they feel bad about your well, and it is making THEM feel better to know that they are making things right in case they DID cause your well to go dry.
 
Giving it to charity would be rejecting the end purpose of the gift. It is so the donor doesn't worry that their actions harmed you.

On a way smaller scale, when our new dog chewed up DS visiting friend's shoes I paid to replace the shoes ($30) even though other Mom said they were old. Otherwise i would have felt bad.
 
I think you should take it. It seems like they will not take no for an answer anyways! Maybe you could sponser a few needy families this Christmas. That would make them happy you took thier check, and you happy that you could help someone! You have some good Karma!
 
I can see both sides here. If you are really uncomfortable about keeping the money and using it for the well, why not use it for a charity? That would buy a lot of food for the local food pantry at a time they really need it. Or a lot of Angel Tree presents for some local kids.

Then you can send them a Christmas card that says "A donation has been made in your name to XYZ organization". Just don't mention how much;)

:thumbsup2 What she said!
 
Send it my way, I will use it to by a new heater. No, the donation suggestion is a great idea.

Suzanne
 
You could compromise. Tell them that you kept half for the well and sent the other half to a charity.
 
I agree. Keep it. Thank them graciously. Put it toward the cost of the new well. That's what they intended for you to do with it so it's best to honor their wishes. Also, keep helping them out and watching their house while they're away and be thankful for having such nice neighbors!
 
I have been given several large gifts, and each time I felt so uncomfortable accepting it (even if I did something to spur the gift giving). It's hard but I've learned to accept their generosity, thank them profusely (verbally and written), and use it on something worthwhile.

The last time, I put it right into our savings acct because it was running dangerously low.

I think the charity donation idea is a great one if you want to do something in their honor.
 
I can see both sides here. If you are really uncomfortable about keeping the money and using it for the well, why not use it for a charity? That would buy a lot of food for the local food pantry at a time they really need it. Or a lot of Angel Tree presents for some local kids.

Then you can send them a Christmas card that says "A donation has been made in your name to XYZ organization". Just don't mention how much;)

ETA: OP your avatar freaked the heck out of me!!! I thought maybe I had some all new mod powers that I didn't know about before!!!:rotfl:
:rotfl:



Thanks everyone for your insight. I still want to talk this over with my husband. But it's nice having third party opinions.:goodvibes
 
I have been given several large gifts, and each time I felt so uncomfortable accepting it
I think the charity donation idea is a great one if you want to do something in their honor.


But this isn't a gift, it's compensation for work the OP has to do on their well -likely due to the actions of the neighbors.
The neighbor asked around and spent a lot of time doing research into whether their actions could have caused the problem with the OP's well, and obviously felt strongly enough that they were at fault to have offered to help pay for the OP's well.
If I were the neighbor and found out that the check had been donated to charity I'd be pretty upset, and it might even cause me to be uncomfortable around the OP.
Why can't you just graciously accept what has been offered?:confused3
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom