Help me pick between these 3!

[LeahA]

First night of vacation. Staying at Boardwalk. We like both Fish and Steaks. Would you choose Flyin Fish-which we've been too many years ago and loved. Yachtmans Steakhouse or Cape May Clam Bake?

2 adults/3 kids/no dining plan

 

[JLS]

I would choose the Flying Fish. It is the closest to you, and I think it is the best food. You can still get a steak there. Without the dining plan it is a better deal to go to Flying Fish than Cape May Clambake. The buffets are great on the dining plan but without the plan they are really overpriced. The Cape May food is decent but not worth $40 per person plus tax and tip.

 

[GAN]

Given you've already been to Flying Fish -I would go with Yachtsman or even possibly Shula's.

 

[tinacaplan]

Flying Fish is excellent. We ate at Cape May last summer and thought it was horrible, borderline inedible. I think it actually affected how I felt about Disney dining the whole rest of the trip. It is also super expensive to do the buffets when you're not on the DDP and they're not a good deal, IMO.

 

[baler31]

Flying Fish is a great choice or my favorite is Bluezoo at the Dolphin.