Thanks for the votes so far, please keep them coming!
Here are my views on the choices, so far:
CBR: Haven't stayed here in 10 years. I remember it being gorgeous, and with the new pool completed, it will really tempt my "Captain Jack." I stayed at the Poly this past April, and love any tropical theming.
POR: Our home-away-from-home. This is where we normally book and we both love it, but I am starting to wonder if we shouldn't expand our horizons
POFQ: Again, love the theming and smallness of the resort, but the food court decor freaks us both out. We are not clown people! And the slide in no way appeals to DS. It would be for convenience only.
OKW: Never stayed here before, but looks quite tranquil, and I may be able to book 5 nights for around $600 (studio). Unfortunately, we want 7-8 nights which would mean a split stay, and with it being so spread out with not as many bus stops, we would probably need a car which, to me, defeats the purpose of staying IN Disney. Also love that we would get a small kitchenette (microwave!)
Thanks again!