First - I'm a huge fan of staying onsite. I love the feel of staying in a Disney Resort. Period.
However (and it's a big however) - our most recent stay (we just returned on June 6th) we opted for an off-site condo at a very, very nearby property and - I can't believe I'm saying this - I don't know that we'll stay onsite again until a) our kids are older and we can afford 2 standard connecting rooms, or b) we are able to secure at least a 2 bedroom accomodation somewhere on property or c) we win the lottery.
Our kids are 5 and 8 and they need to be in bed at 8:30 or 9om at the latest. My older child has proven to us on many occasions that if she gets less than 10 hours of sleep she is an absolute terror. Not joking. She is the grumpiest child when she is tired - very inflexible, moody, you get the picture. I'm praying she outgrows this. My 5 year old is more laid back. She'll get a little whiney if she doesn't get her beauty sleep but it's nothing like my older child. Point being - the kids must be asleep at a reasonable hour or the next day will be a struggle.
The condo we rented was brand-spankin' new and absolutely gorgeous. It was decorated totally Disney - Safari Disney to be exact. We had 3 bedrooms (K, Q, 2T) a fully stocked kitchen with all the comforts of home, a full-sized washer and dryer, large flat-screen tv in the livingroom, tv's in all the bedrooms (with DVD), high-speed internet access, a screened-in balcony, a beautiful pool with water-slide, what have I left out? Oh yes, it took exactly 7 minutes from lot to lot to get to AK, and between 12 and 16 minutes to get to the rest of the parks (I mean from the time we backed out of the parking slot to the time we pulled into our WDW parking slot).
I cannot say enough about having all the space we had. I don't think I will ever stay in a standard room with my girls again. Being able to snuggle in bed with them, read them their bedtime story, kiss them goodnight and leave the door open just a crack (night-lights provided) was priceless. Making pancakes and bacon for breakfast or just tossing cereal and yogurt on the table was also a wonderful plus - not to mention munching on the late night Oreo's and milk from our own fridge.
Dh and I were discussing the fact that even if we did stay at a Disney resort - we would not be able to take advantage of the Extra Magic Hours that staying onsite affords you. Our kids are just at an age that we cannot burn the candle at both ends - at least not without consequence.
I know that there are purists that will only go for the entire Disney experience. I can completely appreciate that. The last time we stayed onsite we stayed at the Animal Kingdom Lodge and loved every minute of it. Someday we will return to the WDW properties. In the meantime, we will stay where we have the space to stretch out and relax......did I mention that we only paid $99/night? That's another big plus. That will allow us to return to WDW even sooner than if we had paid $200 or $300 (or more) per night.
SOrry for the length of this post.