I voted for Fire Coral. It seems flashy yet refined.
While you are at it, you should totally get one of these mermaid seaweed tops to complete your look.
http://www.etsy.com/shop/MerBellaStudios
btw....we need a mermaid smiley. We have a pirate so it would be fitting.
I actually have a home made sea weed shells top, but in the water, it's hard to see the full look in the water. At one point in time, it had a star fish, but believe it or not, the star fish didn't survive the salt water?! Anyway I need to add that back too before next year. Here is another photo that might show you the shell top (in its former glory) better.
https://sphotos-b.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash3/923452_105636076305318_866438223_n.jpg
https://sphotos-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash3/944810_116989405169985_697985025_n.jpg
I think you can see the sea weed better in this one maybe?
My shells have held up pretty good, but I spent over 18 hrs sewing/glueing them by hand!
______
Someone asked about the tail itself, they actually can be quite expensive as they are from a swim training company. They were designed to help 'exercise' sports swimmers to develop their dolphin kicks when they start the races I guess? Us mer people have taken them over. When I first got my tail, I just stuck two regular snorkel style flippers in them. Then I found the single monofin at a liquidator shop, no kidding, for $2.50! I wanted to die! I had to pick up a replacement strap for it, but holy moly I was SO happy! It looks great in all the photos and swims well. I want one stiffer version next if I can get my hands on it. This is the company that makes them and had have a wide range and style and varying stiffnesses (the harder, the more 'challenging', this one is called the Wave and is pretty flexible, considered a 'beginner' level.)
http://aquaworld.net/fins/monofin_wave/ (this is the one I have.)
FINIS is the company that makes the monofin inserts. You can either purchase the entire tail kit that comes with your color 'tail' and an insert fin like this, or you can just buy the 'tail cover' (which is what I do) and then either buy your own monofin or use your snorkel fins, etc., whatever you want to do. I have noticed the monofin gets nice propulsion that is very natural for me, so I recommend even the low end monofin if you can find/order one that is a good price because its more efficient power (you don't have to work to use the legs in unison, if that makes sense.) Some can cost $70, if you find one for $40, not bad, if you can do less than that, even better!
_________________
Thats a super cute story. She has a mermaid troupe! Love that. I noticed she is exactly my age...31... there must be something to that...as in LITTLE MERMAID coming out in 1989 when we were 6..very memorable time... (and a blonde too! Talk about cookie cutter!) I wish I had a silicon tail, but alas, I'm happy with my $70 hobby vs $5000!
Thanks for everyone's input so far! It's kinda nice after a busy day at work to think about just fun stuff for once... (ok a lot, but still!
Btw, I have been hoping for a mermaid icon for a while now!