Help me decide! Last ADR!

[emilyclaire]

Okay, my 180 days is approaching on April 17th. While home sick from work yesterday, I finalized the itinerary (as best as I can without TGM's recommended days out yet), and here are the ADRs I came up with:

Sunday Oct. 14th: Boma (dinner)
Monday Oct 15th: Le Cellier (dinner)
Tuesday Oct 16th: Liberty Tree Tavern (lunch)
Wednesday Oct 17th: Teppanyaki Dining Room (dinner)
Thursday Oct 18th: Mama Melrose's Fantasmic Package
Friday Oct 19th: Spoodles or San Angel Inn before Epcot EMH

So what's the verdict, Spoodles or San Angel Inn? If it helps, we will be coming over from AK to either Boardwalk or Epcot for dinner, then seeing Illuminations before Epcot EMH. This is our last day, so we made it a long one. We can always sleep on the plane on Saturday! I keep reading great things about Spoodles on here, but at the same time I love the beauty of San Angel Inn. Can't decide!

 

[Disneyolic]

That's funny to me because I had almost the same dilemna. I originally booked San Angel Inn but, because of so many negative comments about it, began to rethink my ADR. I have since changed our ADR to Spoodles and Garden Grill. I needed both just because I am not totally sure which one will be the best for us. It depends on how much the kids really want to see Chip and Dale...

 

[sunny04]

I voted for Spoodles because I LOVE the Boardwalk area. I think it is the most fun area to be in, and would be a nice and beautiful end to your trip. San Angel Inn would be nice too, so I don't think you can go wrong with either choice you make. I just went to the Boardwalk for the first time in March, and fell in love, so I'm a little biased at the moment.

 

[disprincessatheart]

If you're already doing 2 parks in one day, save yourself the walking and transferring around and just go straight to EPCOT for dinner.

 

[MagicMe]

I voted for San Angel. We've been there two years in a row and loved it both times. The boardwalk actually doesn't attract me as I grew up near the Jersey shore (the original boardwalks!) so there is nothing really fascinating about it to me.

 

[emilyclaire]

The boardwalk actually doesn't attract me as I grew up near the Jersey shore (the original boardwalks!) so there is nothing really fascinating about it to me.

This is a good point. DH grew up near Philly and spent many summer weekends at the shore as well. I asked his opinion last night based on food alone--- and he didn't care one way or the other. I will bring up the fact that one's on the Boardwalk tonight and see if I get any kind of reaction.

 

[lovmy2girls]

We love mexican food, and the atmosphere at San Angel just make it all that much better. Its one of the few places we have done over, maybe its the alcohol, those margarettas are great. Anyway, Its neat sitting by the river. And the food has always been great and the service too has been good.

Yes...the tables are close, and dark, but we enjoyed ourselves.

Good luck making your choice.
[

 

[emilyclaire]

San Angel it is! I showed DH this thread last night, ran the menus by him one more time, and we both decided after a day at AK, we really don't need to make the trek from Boardwalk to Epcot with a full belly and tired feet. Thanks to everyone who voted, and I can't wait for the lovely atmosphere of San Angel!

 

[momandseandodisney]

Okay, my 180 days is approaching on April 17th. While home sick from work yesterday, I finalized the itinerary (as best as I can without TGM's recommended days out yet), and here are the ADRs I came up with:

Sunday Oct. 14th: Boma (dinner)
Monday Oct 15th: Le Cellier (dinner)
Tuesday Oct 16th: Liberty Tree Tavern (lunch)
Wednesday Oct 17th: Teppanyaki Dining Room (dinner)
Thursday Oct 18th: Mama Melrose's Fantasmic Package
Friday Oct 19th: Spoodles or San Angel Inn before Epcot EMH

So what's the verdict, Spoodles or San Angel Inn? If it helps, we will be coming over from AK to either Boardwalk or Epcot for dinner, then seeing Illuminations before Epcot EMH. This is our last day, so we made it a long one. We can always sleep on the plane on Saturday! I keep reading great things about Spoodles on here, but at the same time I love the beauty of San Angel Inn. Can't decide!

do you know the park hours for these dates? I am going Sept 27th til the 9th of Oct, and I want to figure out the park times before I decide where to eat

 

[Disneyolic]

do you know the park hours for these dates? I am going Sept 27th til the 9th of Oct, and I want to figure out the park times before I decide where to eat

You can see the park hours at the official Disney World website. Here is a link to the park hours:

Park Hours for MK