Help me choose! WCC or Tony's Town Square.

[mickeysgirl17]

Which would you choose?

 

[Married_Him_@_Disney]

I'll probably be the only one that selects Tonys. .. but I cannot help it! I just love the spaghetti and meatballs!

 

[galnar]

WCC. I'd swim there from the MK if I had to...

 

[GoofyWaterCoaster]

I just went to Tony's and it was amazing! The food was perfectly cooked and the service was great

 

[spalady]

I have to say WCC.

 

[INdisbound]

WCC for sure!! Good food & great atmosphere. Tony's has mediocre food at best and nothing special in the atmosphere department.

 

[My2Angels]

Not a hard choice!! WCC definitely! I like Tony's okay, but the WCC is so much fun!!!

 

[Crystal824]

I've not been to WCC, but I have been to Tony's and must vote WCC. I've been to Tony's 3 times. The first time the food and service were good, but that was in 1999. The second time was in 2005. The food was great; the service was not. The last time in 2008, both the food and the service were just ok...not terrible but not particulary good either. For me, I'm giving Tony's a rest for awhile.

 

[JMD]

I voted for WCC.

 

[DizzDoll]

WCC. It's a blast. We had so much fun there, and my daughter was razzed constantly by our server. We had some great laughs, and my daughter was a great sport about it.

 

[ChristaDeVil]

I've never been to Tony's, but WCC is something that has to be experienced at least once. The atmosphere is crazy. We are loud people, and we fit in great here. There's constantly something going on. The food is incredible, but there's so much of it!!!! The only problem that I have with WCC is that it takes a looooong time to eat there. It's an event. So, don't book dinner there if you plan to do anything else that night (except roll into bed and pass out from a meat-induced coma).

 

[marciemouse]

I've never been to either, but I picked WCC. It sounds like so much fun, and the skillet looks great. Most of the Tony's reviews I've read have said it's just really average.

 

[tlriv5]

I voted for WCC, we have never been to Tony's though. I will say our last trip WCC was my dd's favorite place to eat!! They loved the food and the atmosphere. It was so much fun. We did not find it too loud or rowdy as others would say. You are at WDW, the most fun place on earth! When we had to pick our ADR's for this trip my dd's insisted we go back, so we are and I can't wait.

 

[TifffanyD]

I voted for WCC. I can't support a place that has a lady and tramp dinner that includes no pasta OR meatballs

 

[goofypooh]

WCC for sure!! Good food & great atmosphere. Tony's has mediocre food at best and nothing special in the atmosphere department.

Ditto!!

 

[rentayenta]

Which would you choose?

We love Tony's. If you love old school Disney and Lady and the Tramp, then it's pure magic. I also agree that their food is delicious. It was one of our best meals overall. If you decide on Tony's request a table near the Lady fountain. They have stained windows with different movie scenes. It's really sweet.

 

[Pirate Me]

WCC. The atmosphere is GREAT. Hard to compare the two though.

 

[mrslane]

I've posted reviews about Tony's before. Chef Boy Ardee could vomit a better meal. WCC is not what it used to be in terms of food quality, but it's still a great meal with great atmosphere. The food and service are superior to Tony's. This is just my opinion.

 

[SGMCO]

I voted Tony's--
we had the BEST TS meal of our Whole Trip last Sept.
We didn't order any typical Spaghetti dish--
we ordered, the Grilled Salmon, NY Strip Steak and Bianca Pizza--
The food was very good --we ate everything on our plates.
Loved the Atmosphere and the Wait Staff was Very
attentive and Nice.
We made ADRs for early lunch 11:30am with no wait to be
seated.
We are looking forward to eating there again this upcoming trip.

 

[meriface11]

hands down WCC. food is very good and it is a ton of fun for both kids and adults.