Have you been to Mystic Pizza in Ct?

aristocatz

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 22, 2009
Messages
4,887
If not, you need to go there immediately-their pizza is so good!

We went there today and honestly, the pizza was just as good as they make it out to be in the movie lol ;)
 
If not, you need to go there immediately-their pizza is so good!

We went there today and honestly, the pizza was just as good as they make it out to be in the movie lol ;)

I went once about 20 years ago. It wasnt great. It was good, but not worth my long drive to get there. If Im ever in the area again, Ill give it another whirl....
 
Several times. It was good, but if you really want delicious pizza, go to Pepe’s or Modern Pizza in New Haven, CT. That’s where the best pizza is.
 
Several times. It was good, but if you really want delicious pizza, go to Pepe’s or Modern Pizza in New Haven, CT. That’s where the best pizza is.

Thanks! We live out in Western MA & it is very difficult to find good pizza out here. Will check them out next time we are in CT!
 
Thanks! We live out in Western MA & it is very difficult to find good pizza out here. Will check them out next time we are in CT!
Pepe’s is historically known for being one of the best pizza places. The Little Italy neighborhood in New Haven is packed with amazing Italian food.
 
There's a Pepe's in Mohegan Sun too if that is closer for you than New Haven! I like Mystic Pizza but it isn't my favorite. Pizzetta in Downtown Mystic is good as well, and Mango's in Old Mystic Village!
 
We went once and didn't get the hype. We live in nj though where there is a mom&pop pizza shop on just about every corner.
 
There's a Pepe's in Mohegan Sun too if that is closer for you than New Haven! I like Mystic Pizza but it isn't my favorite. Pizzetta in Downtown Mystic is good as well, and Mango's in Old Mystic Village!

Thanks for this info. Ive seen it there before, but didnt realize it was anything above or beyond a regular pizza counter with mediocre pizza! Im going to Mohegan Tuesday, Ill give it a try.
 
It’s good but it’s not the best. I do buy the frozen pizza every so often, again good.

There's a Pepe's in Mohegan Sun too if that is closer for you than New Haven! I like Mystic Pizza but it isn't my favorite. Pizzetta in Downtown Mystic is good as well, and Mango's in Old Mystic Village!

There are Pepe’s all over the state. We went to the one up in Manchester a few years ago because we were shopping at buckland hills and it was gross! So they are not all the same!
 
When the movie came out, Mystic Pizza was notoriously mediocre according to my local friends. But it's still open, so it has to be decent or even improved.

Pepe's in New Haven is a thin crust style pizza if you like that. They have locations all over the state and while the "headquarters" in NH still has a line out the door, the reviews on the newer locations are mixed. It all comes down to the oven, it appears. I'm a medium to Sicilian crust girl, so don't frequent there much. Two of my kids love it though. My other two are like their mom and like thick crust Greek pizza.

The best Italian food in CT - the best array of any international or American food actually - can be found in either New Haven or Waterbury in my opinion.
 
We enjoyed it when we went but it was not what I was expecting. When I think pizza, I think NY style; thin, big slices (I'm on Long Island so that is what we are used to). Mystic Pizza is more of the deep fried type of pizza. Like a higher end version of Dominos or Pizza Hut, imo. It was good for the type of pizza it is. I think we had enjoyed it overall more for the experience.
 
We enjoyed it when we went but it was not what I was expecting. When I think pizza, I think NY style; thin, big slices (I'm on Long Island so that is what we are used to). Mystic Pizza is more of the deep fried type of pizza. Like a higher end version of Dominos or Pizza Hut, imo. It was good for the type of pizza it is. I think we had enjoyed it overall more for the experience.

My grandmother was from LI and we used to order from Sammy's in Bellemore (I think) whenever we were down there. So good. Wondering if there are still open if you're in that area.
 
My grandmother was from LI and we used to order from Sammy's in Bellemore (I think) whenever we were down there. So good. Wondering if there are still open if you're in that area.

If it is Sammy's Inferno, it seems to still be open. I had to google because I'm in Suffolk County. If it is the same place, it looks pretty good. I'm not too far from Bellemore. I may check it out if I'm ever in the area and looking for some pizza!
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom