I love the Deluxes. That said, we like to save a few hundred dollars by staying at a Value for 1-2 nights.
This summer we started by Poly, then BWI, and ended by a night at POP, both of us expecting POP to be a major let down after being in Deluxes for a week. Well, we LOVED Pop.
The store is great, possibly the best store of all the resorts. Food court was good, the resort itself is really cute, funny little things everywhere. We had a room in the 80's section and it was quiet.
We liked it so much that we're going back in a couple weeks, after AKL.
And remember, even if the resort is not exactly to your liking, you have 4 awesome parks to keep you busy.