We ate at Tony's last week. My son and I both had the chicken parm and both enjoyed it. It wasn't the greatest meal ever, but I thought it was very good.
Let me add that the service we had at Tony's was the best service we had all week with 8 nights on the dining plan. We were seated immediately, everything was brought out fast, drinks were refilled, etc. I had also read many bad reports - don't know if things are getting better or we just got really lucky.