I went on 10/7 and was able to purchase the pins from nights 2 and 3 (the first night's pin had sold out) at Uptown Jewelers (on Main St). In order to get that night's pin, you had to go into the photo shop, which is right next to Tony's resturant on the square. If you are on the square and facing the castle, it's on the right side. Perhaps you went to the wrong shop. We were in there at around 11pm the night we made our purchase.