We have it, its fun. So far my 5 year old likes it the best, my 9 year old is less interested. Definitely like Clue. It teaches deductive reasoning, and won't let you solve the case until you have "evidence" to prove 4 different elements - height, weight/shape, hair length, and gender - of the guilty party. So even when you think you know who the guilty one is, you can't prove their guilt until you've found all the clues. Only thing is, the clues are not hard to find - they have a big ? shape over them. I think it would be better if you had to hunt for them. We have only tried it in "novice" and "detective" levels though, not the expert level, so maybe it gets harder to find the clues once you unlock that level of difficulty.