The Illuminations is much closer.
The pontoon boats (of which there are 5) is $160. and can hold 12 people.
The "breathless" is $175. ...its a vintage cris craft cruiser..but seats are seperated by the in-board engine and everyone must be seated...dont get it!!
I would do the pontoon, you must start calling 90 days in advance of the trip...and start calling @ 7AM on the button!!!