For me personally, I understand wanting to maximize the value of the dining plan, but if the quality of the food is average or lower but at a higher price, it's not worth it for me. I would much rather enjoy my meal. With that said, I would pick Sanaa and The Wave. I personally think that Cape May is your typical buffet quality food. That is, pre-made food placed on a table so that droves of people can pile it high and wide on their plates. IMO, it's quantity over quality. From my experience, I thought the crab legs were rather thin and a bit stringy; The same quality I can find where I live sitting on any buffet table at a local Chinese buffet on a Friday or Saturday night. Cape May is not a place I will be visiting again any time soon, if ever, for dinner.