Good/Bad Internet and eBay Pin Sellers

[AmyPond]

Sorry. I can edit my post but I guess it wouldn't matter since it was quoted. Sorry about that.

 

[pixiewings71]

Oh Amy, no worries!! This thread is just huge and it takes a lot to get thru all 59 pages so if we can start a new thread with questions on specific pins that would help. It's not a problem at all, I'm glad you posted here.

 

[horselover]

I also wanted to pop in with more feedback on Domimgood, I am watching 1 pin he has up for auction and also some silly bandz. I did notice that he has some LE fairy pins up with photos of the front and back, the photo of the back you can clearly see what we are referring to when we say there's a border around the edge, that's not supposed to be there, those Mickey heads are supposed to go all the way off the edges of the back. I don't want to post a link but if you do a search for his eBay name and scroll and few pages back you'll see what I'm referring to. So he definitely needs to be at least on the yellow list. Like I said, I am watching a pin but if I do end up with it it will be added to my collection and not traded.

I went to his page & I see exactly what you're saying. Here's my question though. If this seller has taken the time to post pics of the front & back of the pins (most sellers don't) is he hoping buyers don't know any better or is he just an uneducated seller that thinks he/she has legitimate pins for sale?

I'm starting to think I may give up pin trading. It used to be fun but now it just seems like a lot of work. Having to check every pin against pinpics & worrying about putting scrappers into the system by trading with CMs at the parks. Maybe ignorance was bliss, but too late to go back now.

 

[pixiewings71]

I don't know....I should ask him if he knows about that. But I do know that every pin I got from him with my last purchase looked really great until the next day when I looked under better lighting. Unfortunately I'd already left my good FB for that purchase.

 

[*Meagan*]

WOW! this thread is awesome! Im headed to WDW this December and I am making some gift bags for my younger cousins that are going and I thought it would be sooo fun to start their pin collections!

Im soo happy I found this thread because I was really starting to worry about the sellers on ebay.

I am watching a few from "domimgood" but now Im thinking.. no thanks.
I am now searching the "great" sellers to purchase from them!

Gosh some people are just crooks, sickening what people will do for a buck!

Thanks for the amazing posts!

 

[blockscrappers]

WOW! this thread is awesome! Im headed to WDW this December and I am making some gift bags for my younger cousins that are going and I thought it would be sooo fun to start their pin collections!

Im soo happy I found this thread because I was really starting to worry about the sellers on ebay.

I am watching a few from "domimgood" but now Im thinking.. no thanks.
I am now searching the "great" sellers to purchase from them!

Gosh some people are just crooks, sickening what people will do for a buck!

Thanks for the amazing posts!

It is sick. Unfortunately, there are people who don't care if they buy from scrappers to trade as long as they can trade the pin (the cheaper the better) in the park. In fact some buy the bad pins on purpose so that they can trade for good pins in the parks. Plus the scrappers make a ton of money from big lots so all one can really do is educate themselves and not trade "scrappers" in the parks. Anyhow don't let all this stuff ruin your fun have a great trip!

 

[Running_Bell]

Has anyone ever purchased from Amazon? I did a search for starter sets with lanyard for my DD10 and me to start. They look packaged with Lanyard and 4 pins (various).

Thanks!!

 

[pixiewings71]

I went to his page & I see exactly what you're saying. Here's my question though. If this seller has taken the time to post pics of the front & back of the pins (most sellers don't) is he hoping buyers don't know any better or is he just an uneducated seller that thinks he/she has legitimate pins for sale?

I'm starting to think I may give up pin trading. It used to be fun but now it just seems like a lot of work. Having to check every pin against pinpics & worrying about putting scrappers into the system by trading with CMs at the parks. Maybe ignorance was bliss, but too late to go back now.

So I looked at more of his auctions and found some pins that I know have scrappers (because I have a ton of them lol) and I asked him about the backstamp, he told me "these pins are considered scrappers on pinpics" so yes he knows, and no he doesn't say anything about them being scrappers on the auction pages.

Has anyone ever purchased from Amazon? I did a search for starter sets with lanyard for my DD10 and me to start. They look packaged with Lanyard and 4 pins (various).

Thanks!!

No, I didn't even know Amazon had pins on it.

 

[Broncobilly83]

No, I didn't even know Amazon had pins on it.

Neither did I, but looking at them, it looks like Disney maintains a store front there as well as individual retailers

 

[horselover]

So I looked at more of his auctions and found some pins that I know have scrappers (because I have a ton of them lol) and I asked him about the backstamp, he told me "these pins are considered scrappers on pinpics" so yes he knows, and no he doesn't say anything about them being scrappers on the auction pages.

Wow. Shame on him!



Edit: So I just checked the 1st page & he's not listed in red. Shouldn't he be if he out & out told you he's selling scrappers & not being up front about it? Seems like a good reason to add him to the list to me.

 

[pixiewings71]

yes, I'm sure that Mt Nittany will update that as soon as he can.

 

[Running_Bell]

No, I didn't even know Amazon had pins on it.

Neither did I, but looking at them, it looks like Disney maintains a store front there as well as individual retailers

So, do you think it is safe to think these are authentic. I have found some starter sets with lanyard for as low as 9.95. I'm thinking that would be a great way for us to start out.

 

[pinparrot]

Doe's anyone know what happened to Nannub, don't want to buy from them by mistake. Thanks for any help

 

[kdm0516]

there is a elesabethturner on ebay...the price is really good so I'm thinking it is scrappers but she isn't listed on the first page of this thread. Does anyone know?
thanks

 

[Broncobilly83]

So, do you think it is safe to think these are authentic. I have found some starter sets with lanyard for as low as 9.95. I'm thinking that would be a great way for us to start out.

If it is from the Disney Store located on Amazon, more than likely. They probably set it up to get further exposure as well as use it to help sell some slower products

 

[pixiewings71]

So, do you think it is safe to think these are authentic. I have found some starter sets with lanyard for as low as 9.95. I'm thinking that would be a great way for us to start out.

yes, I'm sure they are ok since they are from Disney And I'm sure that Amazon would not look kindly on people selling scrappers on their site.

Doe's anyone know what happened to Nannub, don't want to buy from them by mistake. Thanks for any help

No, sorry....if you are looking just try one of the green listed sellers on our first page.

there is a elesabethturner on ebay...the price is really good so I'm thinking it is scrappers but she isn't listed on the first page of this thread. Does anyone know?
thanks

there's an elizabethturner that we think is selling scrappers.....

 

[MountNittany]

Okay, so I'm 99.9% sure at least one of the pins I got off ebay is a fake. I can't remember who I got it from because it was over a year ago.

It's a WDI Space Mountain pin. The reason I'm pretty sure it's fake is becaue the stuff on the back is just typed in black. It's flat. Not stamped into it. I feel bad because it's a pin I bought online for my husband. He said he doesn't care though since he doesn't plan on trading it ever.

I thought I'd share pictures of it.

Here's the front -

And here's the back -

It looks silver without the flash. So here's one with the flash. You can't read the words as well here though.

(Sorry if this shouldn't have been posted in this thread. I'm not familiar with this section of the board. Let me know if I should take this elsewhere. I have a couple pins I'm not sure about but I don't know if I should post photos and ask here or somewhere else)

There are 66 people trading it on PinPics, so there could be a scrapper of this pin. That's just pure speculation with little fact.

 

[MountNittany]

I'll read through the thread later and respond/update. Disney was awesome as normal. I picked up a few scrappers, but it seems like the majority of the 2010 HM pins on the lanyards are real. All of the ones I traded for (over 30 HMs) were real.

Also, 64 pins wasn't enough for me for a week. I'll probably go with 100 and bring the rest home next time.

 

[mousestruck]

After reading through this thread, we purchased a large lot of pins from one of the "green list" sellers - Sleepy's Emporium. The price was a bit higher than other sellers, but the others were either on the "red list" or on no list, so I paid a few extra bucks to go with a trusted resource. The pins just arrived and I must say they are much nicer than I expected! I am no expert on scrappers, but they do appear to be authentic -- no duplicates and none in little plastic baggies. There are even a couple that are multi-dimensional or special event pins. I'm very pleased. Thanks to all for the education!

 

[AmyPond]

After reading through this thread, we purchased a large lot of pins from one of the "green list" sellers - Sleepy's Emporium. The price was a bit higher than other sellers, but the others were either on the "red list" or on no list, so I paid a few extra bucks to go with a trusted resource. The pins just arrived and I must say they are much nicer than I expected! I am no expert on scrappers, but they do appear to be authentic -- no duplicates and none in little plastic baggies. There are even a couple that are multi-dimensional or special event pins. I'm very pleased. Thanks to all for the education!

Can I ask...how many did you get and for how much?