I am using Betsy, too...though I ordered when it was Sarah's. In my DH's I put a hat, some Mickey golfballs (he loves golf), a refillable mug, and assorted snacks. My son is an avid pin collector, so I got him a lanyard, pins, arcade card, a matching hat, and snacks. Mine is a smaller version of my son's (no arcade card, fewer pins, etc). I spent just over $250.
If these go well, I will probably order something for my neighbor who is going next month.