Fulton's vs. Alfredo's?

[Snurk71]

I know the two don't serve the same fare. But if you were going to try one of these as a new spot, which would you?

Seems like the feedback on Fulton's has been good food (overall), bad service, high $$$. And Alfredo's is mixed on food opinions and some are turned off by the service.

DW has both on her "wish list" for this December.

Thanks

 

[catheren]

While neither are on our must frequent list .... I would probably do Alfredo's over Fulton's.

Being from the NE seacoast, we are spoiled w/ fresh seafood. Fulton's quality was a let down for our family, as well as service and cleanliness.

 

[EsmeraldaX]

I'd probably do Fulton's since I have never been there, my parents have been there and they keep telling us to go since they love it, and I do not really like Alfredos.

 

[ElizabethB]

We just had a great lunch at Alfredo's about two weeks ago. I was very pleasantly surprised. If you like Fetuccine Alfredo, they serve the best version I've ever tasted (all cheese and butter without the thick white sauce). The fried calamari were excellent and the tiramisu was outstanding. We went there only because it was the only World Showcase restaurant operating for lunch the day of Hurricane Charley. As I said, we were pleasantly surprised. And, we had the most wonderful waitress. Her name is Cinzia. She was charming and delightful and absolutely wonderful with two 9-year-old boys. If you go there, ask for her. You won't be disappointed.

As far as Fulton's, we have only been there once and it was a few years ago, so can't really tell you anything current about it.

 

[jiminy579]

Our dinner at Fulton's was out of this world! The food was incredible, and the service was good. We were celebrating our 10th anniversary and when we told the hostess we were given a table with a great view. I highly recommend them!

 

[April in Disney]

We think these two have the worst service than any other sit down restaurant in WDW. We ate twice at Fulton " food was good, it was expensive but we already knew and was ok with it" service was the first time (C- ) the second time it was (F). Alfredo's the food was just passable (we go to Little Italy few times a year) price was fine, service was inferior.

 

[DepCor0311]

I have never had a bad experience with Alfredo's (service or food). That would be my pick....plus when you are finished...You're in Epcot!

 

[ILUVDXL]

Sorry, we don't like either restaurant. Palio in the Swan has great Itlaian. For seafood I rather go to Flying Fish.

 

[AladdinsPrincess]

I've never had a bad experience at Alfredo's. If you can, sit outside - the atmosphere is very relaxing (not as bustling and crowded as the inside), romantic (especially if it's getting dark), and beautiful!

 

[Aimeedyan]

We had a great exp at Fultons, great food, lovely view, and good service.

Have never done Alfredos since it gets such hit and miss reviews, and my mom has not had a pleasant exp yet.

But neither one are guaranteed hits around here

Guess either is a chance, so choose which food you'd like to have! =)

 

[Wenda]

I ate at both on my trip the week of Aug 14th and loved both. I you love "Americanized" Italian food you will not like Alfredo's. I had veal scalopine and it was spectaculor. The service was very good. As good as any other Disney restaurant we ate at that week. At Fulton's we both got lobster and it was great. Not over cooked as it is at some places. The service there was also very good. We ate in the bar as there was a long wait for the dining room and the waitress was very attentive. Alfredo's was much more relaxing and we walked outside to Illuminations. Fulton's was very loud and crowded and we walked outside to Pleasure Island. They were very different and we loved both.

 

[tinkerb]

well we actually did have a bad experience at Fulton's....we were just a table of two next to a table of eight, the table of eight ordered king crab (over $50 a plate) and we order shrimp (needless to say that table got ALL the service) we had to BEG to get our tea refilled, so I have chosen never to go back to fultons........ why wasn't our money the same as theirs even if it was for a smaller amount?

 

[webray]

We have never been to Fulton's...however..we love Alfredo's. The food/service are wonderful, we have never had a problem with either. The inside is beautiful as well.