Fuji S5200 v Panasonic DMC FZ30 v Koday Easyshare P 850

cmm

Mouseketeer
Joined
May 27, 2005
Messages
446
I have a very old digital camera and a film camera, but am tired of lugging the big old thing around. Thinking of upgrading to a digital camera, but it is very confusing! Don't think I want to spend the money for a DSLR, but these three cameras look pretty good. I think I am favoring the Panasonic. Anyone have opinions and experience with these? I appreciate any comments. Thanks :)
 
Not that this would be the definitive answer to your question, but if it would be helpful to see S5200 samples, please feel free to visit my photobuket site. The WDW 04 and 05 pix were made with my camcorder, but all the rest of the pix were with the S5200. Most were in "chrome" mode, which gives a little more vibrant color:

http://s76.photobucket.com/albums/j11/fasteddiew/

The 5200 has its shortcomings, but for the money (Currently $225-230 from a couple of reputable online merchants) is a pretty decent digital camera.

~YEKCIM
 
Yekcim, what do you think are the shortcomings? I am by no means a great photographer, but my photos are not too bad either. I want something lightweight, with a short response time from the time I hit the shutter til it takes a photo, and something good in low light situations. Seems like the Fuji does not blur - i.e. pretty good stop action? I think I am going to the photo store near my home in a night or two to check them out, but will probably buy online - looks a whole lot cheaper that way.
 

cmm said:
Yekcim, what do you think are the shortcomings? I am by no means a great photographer, but my photos are not too bad either. I want something lightweight, with a short response time from the time I hit the shutter til it takes a photo, and something good in low light situations. Seems like the Fuji does not blur - i.e. pretty good stop action? I think I am going to the photo store near my home in a night or two to check them out, but will probably buy online - looks a whole lot cheaper that way.

Based on your needs, I think the S5200 might be a very good fit for you. The camera has very little shutter lag, which is a pretty good feature for what is basically a P&S "bridge" camera. The low light capabilities are good, again for a P&S. ISO goes up to 1600, although 1600 is pretty noisy. 800 is usable, IMO:

DSCF2839.jpg


It is lightweight, uses AA batteries, and battery life is excellent...I shot all day on a fully charged set of batts, and never had a low batt warning. Macro capability is cumbersome, but gives good results:

DSCF1635.jpg


The S5200 *will* shoot RAW, although I have not used that feature, and have no plans to. One feature I do like a lot is the "chrome" mode which gives more snappy, saturated colors than "standard". All of my WDW pix were shot in Chrome mode; in fact, I don't shoot "standard" anymore, at all.

Dislikes (not in any particular order): xD memory is a bit more expensive than SD; 38-380 equivalent zoom range does not afford a real wide angle option, although the 380mm equivalent tele is very useful; zoom is via W/T toggle switch on the back of the camera, which is (to me) a very inconvenient spot...I would much prefer a manual zoom ring on the lens; flash is not very powerful, and in my experience, is sometimes inconsistent; no hot shoe for accessory flash; images are not as sharp out-of-camera as I would like, and most require some sharpening in PP; learning curve seems a bit steep, to learn how best to use the features of the cam...however, this is my first digicam, so my experience may be typical for new digital cam users.

For a detailed review of the camera, see this:

http://www.steves-digicams.com/2006_reviews/fuji_s5200.html

It was this review, more than anything else, that influenced my decision to buy the Fuji.

A couple final notes:

1. Halfway thru our week at WDW, the power switch, which is a rotating collar around the shutter button, became very balky and hard to turn. Did not affect camera operation, but it became so stiff that I was concerned that I would actually break it, trying to turn the cam on/off. On return, I sent it to the nearest Fuji service center (Atlanta) and just got it back this week, fully repaired, at no charge, under the warranty.

2. IMO, if you are going to go to a b&m store, using their dislplay model and salespeople's expertise to help you evaluate the camera, you should buy the camera from them, not online.

Hope this is helpful; let me know if any more questions.

~YEKCIM
 
The FZ30 just went out of production, soon to be replaced by the FZ50 around Sept. The FZ30 may be hard to find. Don't let the jump from 30 to 50 mean that there may be great advancement in the new camera. Nobody knows whether there will be but the feeling is maybe not. The reason for no 40 is the Japanese for some reason don't like the number four. I read why but can't recall.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top