Welcome gbxxxi, and please, don't let windbags like us keep you away. We rarely rip anyone to shreds unless they REALLY deserve it!
I still think there's some disconnect, so let me see if I can help us understand each other a bit better...
...we have yet to notice a real downfall at the parks or at the resorts.....
I assume you mean service, hospitality, cleanliness, maintenance and the such. My WDW experience only goes back to 2000, but when I factor in my DL experience, I don't disagree with you too much. We've had no problem with service and hospitality, but maybe we are just lucky. Cleanliness seems fine too, though admittedly, I am not looking for issues when I'm visiting. Now, maintenance at WDW isn't something I can comment on too much. Others have said it had deteriorated at WDW, but has been improving. What I do know is that at DL, it DEFINITELY deteriorated and only in the past year or so has that been reversed. A perfect example is the carousel. It was neglected for so long, that when they prepared to take it down to do what they thought would be a routine 6-8 week rehab, they found it was literally falling apart. The roof was riddled with dry rot and had to be completely replaced.
Its still closed.
So overall, my personal experience hasn't really fallen that much, but I can't deny that things like deferred maintenance are not at least a tad disappointing.
However, for my wife and I - whenever we are planning a vacation, Disney comes in first, second and third on our list!
Us too! Well, Hawaii gets thrown in the mix as well, but that's not due to anything Disney is doing wrong.
There is something that is special about Disney. Just driving onto property is magical.... It is a place that you (at least for my wife and I) can go and forget about all your troubles.... It is a magical place..... It is more than the rides and parks. It is more than the resorts and Marketplace. It is the entire package.....
Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes and YES!
I have yet to get to the point some of you have - where you are cynical of everything the Disney company does or where you seemingly go to Disney in search of something to complain about.
I can only speak for myself, but I'd substitute skeptical for cynical. I know you said "seemingly", so you are admitting its only a perception, but again, I can only speak for myself when I say I do not look for something to complain about. That maybe why I haven't really noticed any problems with service and cleanliness. I go still EXPECTING everything to be fine in these areas, and I haven't been disappointed.
But - I can tell you if that day ever came, I would not continue to spend money on vacations down there.
I proabably would too. But I think this is where the disconnect is. Honestly, Disney could probably cease any new development of any new attractions, activities, parks, anything, and I'd still return for years.
But I also know this would be short-changing the capabilities of the company and its people, as well as its legacy. I also know that eventually, this strategy would have to lead to the eventual demise of everything Disney is or was.
Now, I don't see things as being THAT far to the end of the spectrum. However, they have moved in that direction. Yes, the atmosphere and classic attractions are WONDERFUL, and always will be. But how can I possibly look at most of DCA, and at Dinorama, and a stagnant Epcot, and all of these other "new" decisions and not see a problem?
It doesn't mean my experiences at WDW have been ruined. But it does mean this company is slipping into mediocrity. That its relying on its loyal fan base, and wonderful things created by the company in the past. They are milking the cash cow for all its worth, and that's a strategy that will inevitably fail in the long run.
And I'm hoping to still be going to WDW with my grandchildren with them as "Wow'd" as we all are.
Eisner is not perfect and he probably should go - but how can anyone be positively optimistic that his replacement will be better?
One cannot. However, if Eisner does get the boot, it means that somebody has realized that at least some of the things he was doing were detrimental to Disney, and logic would dictate the new regime would likely make some changes.
Its my optimism that makes me think those changes will be for the bettter. But until Eisner is at least forced out of his bunker, the optimism for the future remains suppressed.
You see, I'll bet there is very little difference between you and I in how we view the current WDW as it stands. After all, we both go because we have wonderful times there.
Being a skeptic, or a realist (imho) about the direction Disney is heading is a separate issue from where it is at. From my point of view, Disney is such a magical place, that it would probably take another 10-15 years of ineptness to really even make me think twice about going back.
But its heading in that direction nonetheless, and I'd hate to see such a wonderful place become ordinary.